This is the solution to a puzzle contained within a story that never happened and never will. If you'd rather solve the puzzle yourself than just read the solution, go read the story instead.

Here's the solution to the 'logic puzzle' that no one solved in eight years (possibly due to simple lack of interest). Parts of the original story relevant to the solution are copied below, and irrelevant parts are generally deleted or shortened. The puzzle was stated at the end of the original story, as follows:

Who went onstage wearing only yellow ducky panties? Whom did the mayor spank? And how many more swats did the oldest girl get before the grand finale?

What are all their names (full names for the three captives), ages, order they were tied and where, order they were chosen and by whom? What panties were they wearing (at first!), what were each of them spanked with, and how many swats? You have everything you need to figure it out, just not all here in this story.

In other words, fill in all the gaps (with no guarantee those three aren't all on the same line):

Besides the story with the puzzle, three other stories are needed for the full solution to the puzzle, hence only readers who had also read those stories could have got it. They are Night Riders, and Brittany and Caitlin's First Communion, and (attached to the same story) Cujo's Bitch. It also helps to read either The Ballad of Brownie Troop 432, or Little Nicole on Stage, or Little Nicole's Day at the Farm to understand the location of this story and the men of BR&T, but you could solve the puzzle without knowing anything from those stories. People who have never read any of my other stories will be completely lost and gain nothing from this solution and might as well stop now.

BR&T date: probably October or November 1995

The BR&T men took three captive BR&T girls and two free-range BR&T girls to the BR&T Stage for the entertainment of some special visitors.

So obviously there are five girls.

"You first, Elisa," one chuckled, pulling a girl from the cage, as the other girls cowered as far from the cage door as they could get. Four men carried her up onto the stage and tied her standing between two posts, and removed her Rainbow Brite panties so she stood naked in front of the visitors.

"I want that one!" said the judge gleefully, as the object of his attention squirmed.

Remember this: the judge wants a particular girl, and he's clearly referring to the only girl who is already tied, so that's Elisa.

"You don't get to pick first. I do!" said another, though he was keenest on getting the six-year-old, still in the cage.

Whoever gets first pick will automatically get the girl he wants, who is six years old and wasn't the first one to be tied. "The six-year-old" means no other girl is that age.

The BR&T men next brought another seven-year-old girl onto the stage and tied her between two posts beside the first.

"I'll bet you can't wait to get these panties off, can you?" a man teased her. They tied her and stripped off her panties and the BR&T man then held the panties in front of her face, showing her the cute designs, making the girl scream and struggle wildly and turn her head away. "Aww, don't you like cute widdle doggies anymore? I heard they like you a lot!!" he teased.

"Another seven-year-old girl" says she and Elisa are both 7. She clearly dislikes what's on her panties, obviously doggies.

"Super cute," observed one visitor, eyeing her appreciatively, "but I think I'll avoid this one. Her parents pestered me for weeks trying to get me to call out the National Guard to look for her when she disappeared."

Someone with the authority to call out the National Guard says he will not choose the one with the doggie panties unless he has no choice. Only the President or a Governor of a state can call out the National Guard.

The BR&T men brought forward a sister of one of the girls already on the stage. "Oh, please, please don't hurt her! Please don't do this to her, too!" she begged them, in vain. Indeed, as soon as the third girl had been tied by her wrists at the end of the line away from the others, stripped of her panties, and tied the rest of the way, the BR&T men handed a visitor a seven-stranded leather whip and let him give her the first of thirteen swats she would get that day, just to get her sobbing so the last two girls would have something frightening to listen to as they got brought up onto the stage and tied like the others.

Now you know the five girls are getting tied in a line, not a circle or some such thing. Furthermore, the 3rd girl to be tied is tied "at the end of the line" which you can arbitrarily assign to stage position 1 (since if she was in 5, the solution could be flipped so she was in 1 anyway). But since that's "away from the other girls" (who are beside each other) they can't be in positions 2 and 3, and must be in positions 3 and 4, or 4 and 5, in either order.

"I like this thing! Nice effect!" the senator declared, pleased by the way she had jerked and gasped as the knotted strands brutally raked across her soft mounds. "I advise no one else to choose it. Understood?" Though that was technically against the rules, the other visitors didn't want to argue with him.

Now you know what the senator will be using, even if you don't know anything else about him or her. Also, "this thing" instead of "that thing" proves the senator is holding it, not watching someone else. You don't know whether the girl he swatted is the one he'll choose.

"Maybe we should have put the sisters together," one BR&T man suggested, as he finished tying the fifth girl's ankle to the lowest eye bolt on the post beside her.

"Which ones?" another asked.

"Any of them, or all of them," came the answer.

"Leave 'em where they are. I like it better when they're separated," another said.

This exchange is important in helping you find girls who fit from my other stories. There are at least two pairs of sisters, or possibly three in the same family, and none of them are tied beside their own sister. Readers familiar with my stories will already know that there's only one girl named Elisa, she's 7, and she has a sister named Ivana, who is 5. That fits everything you know in the puzzle so far.

They have no other sister, so there must be other sisters there. Ivana is in position 1, but if there were three sisters in the other four places, at least two would be together. So there's just one other pair of sisters, and one loner.

Since Elisa and Ivana are "free range BR&T girls" (they go home between uses), the other three girls must be the three captive BR&T girls (they never get to go home again). There might not be enough information yet to definitely identify them, but you can eliminate everyone from the Kidnapped Schoolgirls stories, because that's from 1986, and this story happened in 1995 ("BR&T Date" is when it happened in the timeline of the fantasy universe). The BR&T men would have lost interest in even the youngest of those girls long before now.

With five pretty girls' pretty panties piled up in the center of the stage (Strawberry Shortcake on top), and the cage left empty and awaiting the girls' return, the preparation ended and the choosing began.

You can add one line, since these panties are on the top of the pile of five panties taken off the girls and thrown on the pile one by one:

"I'll take this one," one visitor said, "and I'll show her why that unicorn wanted to be where it was, and what it wanted to do there with that horn!"

The first one to choose a girl, remember, wanted "the" six-year-old, so that's who he got. She was clearly wearing unicorn panties, until they were taken off her, so she can't be the first one tied (Elisa with Rainbow Brite), the second one tied (doggie panties), the third one tied (Ivana, age 5), or the last one tied (Strawberry Shortcake). She must have been the 4th one tied.

"You're next," a BR&T man prompted, and another visitor chose the girl in the center.

"I may not have got the one I wanted, but my ruling is, this sweetie will do nicely," the next visitor joked. "And don't forget," he chided the man who had claimed the girl beside his, "you owe me one swat on the darling you picked."

This deceptively-short snippet gives you lots of information! First of all, since he picked 3rd but didn't get the one he wanted, the one he wanted must have been chosen 1st or 2nd. The judge is the only one who said who he wanted, that being Elisa. "My ruling is" implies it's the judge, and clever readers might remember that a judge issued the divorce decree that forced Elisa and Ivana to ride the night bus, thus explaining why he wanted Elisa but would happily settle for Ivana. Some might have noticed that Ivana is described in that story as a "sweetie" like the person said here. But that's circumstantial evidence you don't need. Here's proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

Since the judge wanted Elisa but she was already chosen 1st or 2nd, but she's 7 and 1st choice chose a girl who is 6, Elisa must have been chosen 2nd - by the man who chose the girl in the center of the line of 5 girls. Put everything you know about Elisa into stage position 3.

Ivana was tied in stage position 1, but the second girl to be tied was beside Elisa and away from Ivana, so she must have been tied in stage position 4.

He chided "the man who had claimed the girl beside his" therefore he must have chosen the girl in stage position 1 (Ivana) or position 5, and the man who already chose the girl beside his, in stage position 2 or 4, must have chosen 1st or 2nd. But 2nd choice picked the girl in the center, so 1st choice must have picked the girl in position 2 or 4. But he picked a six-year-old with unicorn panties, and position 4 was 7 years old and had doggie panties, so 1st choice must have picked the girl in position 2, and she must have been beside the one chosen 3rd, so that must be position 1. Therefore, the judge picked Ivana, case closed.

And since the man he chided owes the judge one swat on his choice, and the senator is the one who took an early swat, the senator is the guy who chose 1st. Combine everything you know about the senator with everything you know about the first choice, and put it in stage position 2.

At that point, you've deduced where on the stage each of the first four to be tied were tied (Elisa 1st in the center, doggie panties 2nd beside her in 4, Ivana 3rd in 1, and the six-year-old 4th in 2 beside Ivana), so the 5th girl to be tied must have been tied in the only remaining place, being the end of the line opposite Ivana, stage position 5. Now you know the Strawberry Shortcake panties must be there, from a previous clue.

Finally, since you've deduced four of the panties in place on the stage, the only one left with unknown panties must have gone on stage wearing the ducky panties.

Here's what you know after all of that is added.

"They're all so pretty it doesn't matter," another noted. He finally selected one of the last two girls, and reading the card on the post on her left, asked, "I get to spank her nineteen swats, using whatever I want, right?"

"Yes, nineteen, the number calculated based on her age, but we'll choose the instruments in reverse order," a BR&T man explained.

The man who can call out the National Guard said he was going to avoid the girl who had the doggie panties, who is one of the two remaining girls. If the man with 4th pick was that man, he would have immediately taken the other girl, not "finally" selected one. Note that the number of swats each girl will get is not her age. There's no way they would want a nineteen-year-old for anything. Blech. Now you also know that choosing what to spank with will go in the reverse order that the girls were chosen.

"Ah don't mind taking this'n, as employee of the week," one of the BR&T men chuckled. "Even chosen last, she's still gorgeous. And since she's the oldest, Ah get to really let 'er have it before we fuck the little fuckrags."

The oldest girl was chosen last (naturally, and not really a choice), and she gets more swats than any of the others. She must be older than 7, to get more swats than two of the other girls who are 7. Thus 4th pick gets to give 19 swats to the girl who has doggie panties, who is 7. Since a seven-year-old will get 19 swats total, that's how many Elisa will get, and since Ivana, age 5, will get 13 swats total, a simple formula gives swats = (3 * age) - 2.

Now there are only two unknown visitors. One of them must be the mayor, and one of them must be president or governor. But one of them chose the girl with doggie panties that the other guy declared he was going to avoid, so that must be the mayor, and the other guy chose Elisa in the center.

The five sobbing helpless naked little fuckrags wailed on hearing that, especially the oldest, since she already knew what it was like, getting spanked by that BR&T man. "Oohhhh please, pleeeease..." she sobbed. To her absolute terror, she saw him raise a long golden plastic rod from the box, with a black handle: the very same rod he'd spanked her with the first time, the day she first met him. "Aaaauuww! AAAAUUuuuwww!!" she screamed as he landed two hard swats on her before even letting the rest pick their weapons. Her bawling disturbed her sister enough to get her bawling again too, even before her own whipping started. He shoved the box over to the next man in line.

Since the three girls who need to be identified are ages 6, 7, and over 7, the sisters can't be twins, eliminating any twins in any stories you might have been considering. Now you know enough to identify two girls from my other stories, which will give you their full names and the one missing age. Last pick of girl gives him first pick of what to swat her with, and he chooses a golden rod which he used on that girl the first time she met him. (Girls in other stories who might have been spanked by the same man with the same rod are ruled out by age or number of sisters.)

Her sister can't be the girl beside her in position 4, and thus must be the girl in position 2, who is going to get a "whipping" from the senator. The only girls who fit all the facts are Brittany Faith McLaran, who is 8, and her sister Caitlin Chastity McLaran, who is 6. Everything fits, including the BR&T dates.

That man rummaged through the choices and raised one. The girl before him cringed. He snickered. "Since I know how much she'll hate it, I'll take the leash and use it way different from what she wishes someone would use it for!"

The BR&T man with the rod leaned toward the other man's girl. Half whispering, he teased her, "Ya know you're goin' back there when we're done with ya, don't ya?" He smirked at her look of despair.

While you were looking at Brittany and Caitlin's story, you probably noticed a girl who is 7, hates doggies, wishes someone would use a leash for something other than spanking her, will "get tired of getting raped by a dog and want to do something else for a while" and despairs when she hears that she's "goin' back there" when they're done using her on the stage.

"I already know what I want," the man on the other end of the line called, eager to get the business - or rather, the pleasure - started. "Hand the extension cord down here then go ahead and take your pick."

"A bit long, isn't it?" said a man pulling out a short section of garden hose for himself and a six-foot electric extension cord for the other man.

"Not if you double it over and hold the ends, with a loop around your hand," he explained, as the man in between passed it to him. "See?" he demonstrated, twirling it in an arc over his head and bringing it down against the stage floor with a sharp CRACK! "It'll mete out what the little sweetie deserves, that's for sure!" he chuckled.

"Aaaahhh don't don't donn't!! Oaahh donnn't!" the little sweetie facing him wailed.

"I never get tired of hearing that!" the man with the hose quipped.

"Then don't ever become President, or you'll lose it for life," a BR&T man advised. "You know, agents all over you forever. Can't have that here, anyway."

In reverse order, the judge chooses next, and asks for the electric cord to be passed down to him. The one with 4th choice of implement because he got 2nd choice of girl takes the rubber hose. The cheater who told people not to choose the whip despite getting last choice of implement still got 1st choice for both. The "man with the hose" is either president or governor, but they advise him to never become president, so he must be the governor of the state where Juliette went missing (and where the stage is?). The grid is completely filled in, leaving only the final question.

"You guys want to spank them all at once, or take turns so you can all watch what all of the others do?" the head BR&T man, Robert Blackrock, asked them.

"Let's take turns and watch the rest for the first swats, but save three swats back to do all together for a grand finale," the senator compromised. He was very good at compromising, and getting everyone to agree, so that's what they did.

The BR&T employee already gave Brittany two swats with the rod, of the 22 she's slated to get, and they're saving back three to do all at once, so she'll get 17 more swats with everyone watching her get it. She'll also have to listen to the other four girls getting a total of 60 swats (1 with the electric cord and 12 with the whip to her little sister, Caitlin), order of the spankings not known, then comes the grand finale of three swats for each of them, all at once.