Chapter Twenty-Five: Sarah
Kari was right. Just a few weeks later, I was sitting in the cafeteria, talking with Kari, when Sarah approached us. "Can I talk to you for a minute?" she asked. "Alone."
I had a good idea what this was about, and by the smirk on her face, so did Kari. "Sure," I said. "One minute." I turned to Kari and whispered in her ear, "Finish your lunch, my Kari, then go to the bathroom. I want you to masturbate to at least one cum. When you are done, you may not clean yourself off in any way. If I am going to have to think about sex, so are you!"
"Yes, sir!" she said, snapping off a mock salute.
Sarah sat across from me, clearly trying to steel herself up to talk to me. While I waited, I examined her. She was a natural redhead with light red hair. Her skin was creamy, covered with a sprinkling of very light freckles. She was well padded; not fat, just what looked like a little baby fat. Her tits were probably only a B, but when she wore a low-cut shirt, they looked so creamy, so soft, like two scoops of the tastiest vanilla ice cream. I'd always wondered if her pubic hair was the same color as the hair on her head. If my hunch was right, I'd probably find out.
"I know about Sandy and Karen," she began.
"What about Sandy and Karen?" I asked.
"I know that you slept with them, and I know that you made them feel great, that you fulfilled their fantasies," she said.
She looked at me for confirmation, but I wasn't giving her any.
"I want you to do that for me," she said.
"What do you want me to do?" I asked.
She looked around, then leaned forward and said, "I want you to make my fantasy come true."
"And what is your fantasy?" I asked.
"I can't tell you here. Can you come to my house tonight at 8 and we can discuss it?" she asked.
"That's pretty late. How long will we be … discussing it for," I asked.
She blushed, a beautiful pink, and rushed to say, "No, I don't mean that. It's just that my parents are going out to a meeting, so we can talk about it in private. It can't be more than about a half hour, or my parents might come back. Could you, please?"
"OK," I said.
I passed Kari in the hall later and grabbed her. "So good to see you," I said, kissing her hand. It smelled terrific. She stuck her tongue out at me, and I said, "The next time I come over, I am going to take that tongue, and put some of what is on your hands on it."
Her tongue quickly retracted, and I said, "Can't wait," before I wandered off.
Later I bumped into Sandy, and I said, "I understand that you've been talking about me."
"I might have bragged a little," she said.
"I hope you didn't puff me up too much," I said.
"I only told the truth," she said, laughing. "Can I help it if people might have been - intrigued - by the truth?"
"You made an offer to me when we were together," I said quietly. "Does it still stand?"
Her eyes got wider and her breathing quickened. "Come home with me after school, and we'll discuss it," she told me.
I met her in front after school, and we drove to her house. She took me to the living room and said, "What offer did you mean?"
"The one where you would take the spanking that I was planning to give to Karen," I said.
"Were you going to punish her?" she asked. "Did you save it for me?"
"Not yet," I said. "I'll tell you a secret. I did punish Karen for talking about me, but I didn't spank her as part of that punishment, because you had taken it for her. But I also told her that she was going to be punished in the same way, every time that I was with someone as a result of what she said. Are you willing to take the spankings for those times as well?"
"Yes," she said.
"OK, then," I said, standing. "I'll come see you when it happens."
"Wait," she said. "You're not going to punish me now?"
"You haven't done anything to show me that you are a bad girl who deserves it, and I am not planning on punishing Karen until after I am with someone else."
"But I am a bad girl," she said. "I've been having these awful thoughts. I've been thinking of boys, putting their mouths on, you know, a dirty place."
"Well, I don't believe that anyone should be punished for their thoughts. People can't help the thoughts that they have. You should only be punished for your actions."
I started to the door and she asked, "But what if someone did that to me?"
"Who would do that? Why would they?"
"You would, because I begged you to!" she said.
"You would beg me?" I asked.
"Yes!" she stood up and slipped her shorts and panties off, then sat on the couch and spread her legs. "Please, will you lick me?"
"But last time I tried, you pushed me away. You told me it was dirty."
"It is, but I want it so bad. Please?" she begged.
I walked back to her, looking at her naked pussy. "I'll make you a deal. I'll lick your nasty pussy, but in return, you have to suck on my cock. Will you do that, you bad little girl?"
She looked shocked that I would ask her that, but she nodded her head. "And then I'd deserve a spanking?" she asked hopefully.
"Probably more than one," I said.
"Oh, god, yes!" she moaned, leaning back and spreading her legs further, holding her lips open with her fingers. I couldn't ignore an invitation like that. I knelt down and dove in. Dirty it wasn't. It was sweet. It was juicy. It was wet. Sandy started gasping almost immediately, and when I added my fingers to the mix, she shrieked.
"Oh, it's so good!" she moaned.
"I thought it was disgusting," I said.
"It is. It's disgusting. It's nasty. Don't stop, please!" she cried.
I didn't stop, not until she had cum all over my face. While she was recovering, I pulled my clothes off. I slipped under her and grasped her tit in one hand while I rubbed her ass with the other.
"Are you going to spank me?" she asked, breathlessly.
"How could I not, when you were so nasty that you begged me to eat you, even when you admit it's disgusting!" I spanked her hard. I didn't bother counting. I figured that as long as Sandy was squirming and moaning under my hand, I should keep going. I would spank her four or five times, then bury my fingers in her pussy. The whole time that I was doing that, she was squirming, rubbing her stomach on my rock hard cock. I must have cycled like that five or ten times before she came on my fingers.
I rubbed her ass as she squirmed some more, then I said, "I believe there is another part of the bargain that you need to keep."
She got up on her hands and knees next to me. "I could feel this on my stomach the whole time that I was being spanked." She jerked it up and down a little.
"Well, your squirming ensured that you will not have to have it in your mouth for too long."
"It's a really dirty thing to do," she said. Then she licked the length of it with her tongue. "It doesn't taste bad." She licked all around, then sucked the head in. As I said, I was already close to the edge from the events of the day, so she didn't really get enough time to do a proper blow job. Still, seeing the head cheerleader looking up at me with my cock in her mouth... not something I was going to forget any time soon.
I thought about cumming in her mouth. In fact, I was thinking about not even warning her, to see what happened when something that dirty went into her mouth. But I decided that I had a better use for my cum. I pulled out of her mouth and got up, pushing her down so that her ass was in the air. I started spanking her again as I stroked myself, and soon I was spurting on her ass.
"Oh, what are you doing?" she asked.
"Giving you a soothing cream for your red ass," I said.
"You came on my ass?" she said in shock, looking back at me, seeing my cock dripping cum on her. "Oh, you did!"
I spanked her some more, moving my sticky cum all over, while my fingers were busy on her clit. Soon she was cumming again, and she collapsed on the couch. I sat next to her, stroking her hair as she recovered. "And you said that I was the nasty one! I can't believe that you came on my ass."
"It's such a lovely ass!" I said. I kissed her forehead and said, "I've got to go."
"Why do you have to leave?" she asked.
"I promised Sarah I'd go to her house for a few minutes tonight," I replied.
"What are you going to do to Sarah?" she asked.
"Let me just tell Sarah how lovely your ass gets when it's so red, then I'll let you know," I said.
"You wouldn't!" she cried.
"If you don't ask about other people, I won't tell other people about you," I said.
"Fair enough," she said.
I went home and showered and did my homework, then went over to Sarah's house. She was very nervous as she led me to the kitchen table.
"If you're this nervous, maybe it's not really for you," I suggested.
"I'm not nervous about what I'm going to ask for, just that I'm asking it. I'm worried about what will happen if people find out," she told me.
"Well, I promise that I won't tell anyone about what you tell me," I said.
She nodded and then said, "OK, here's the thing. I've dated a bunch of guys, and I've slept with a few. The thing is..." She paused for a minute, then said in a rush, "I want to sleep with a woman!"
"I'm not sure if you noticed this, but I'm a guy," I said.
"I know that, you idiot," she said, hitting my arm. Now that she had gotten it off her chest, she seemed a little more relaxed. "I've always been curious about girls. But I couldn't do anything with someone I know. Also, I think I'd be too nervous just with a girl alone; if I do I'd feel like I was a lesbian and I'd freak out. So I thought that you might know someone, someone that no one else knows, that wouldn't spread stuff around about me, and you could both do me."
She looked down shyly, then looked up hopefully. "Do you think that you can?"
I thought about it for a minute, then said, "I do know someone that might fit the bill. She might be a little aggressive with a sexy virgin like you, though."
"I'm not a virgin!" she exclaimed.
"You've been with a girl before?" I asked.
"Oh, you mean like that. That's OK."
"Are you sure?" I asked.
"Yes," she said.
"OK, then I'll call her tonight and let you know when and where tomorrow at school," I informed her.
"Thanks!" she said. She jumped up and hugged me. I hugged her back, then kissed her.
When I got home, I made a call. When a girl whose voice I didn't recognize answered it, I asked, "Is Katherine there?"
"Who is this?" she asked.
"Jake," I replied.
"Katherine, Jake's on the phone," she yelled.
"Oooh, goody!" I heard, and Katherine came on.
"Hi, Katherine," I said. "How are you."
"Good. Are you calling for another round?" she asked.
"Sort of, but not really. I have a favor to ask." I explained the request that I'd gotten, which necessitated explaining the whole series of events leading up to it. By the time that I was done, Katherine was in tears laughing. She asked me to describe Sarah, and when I did, she agreed and gave me a time over the weekend when her roommate would be gone, and we could turn her apartment into a den of iniquity.
"But after this, you owe me one!" she said.
"So I am bringing you a virgin pussy eater, for you to train, and I am going to owe you?" I asked.
"OK, maybe I'll owe you. Invite Cat over sometime and we'll be even."
"I promise," I said.
The next day in school, right towards the end of the day, I approached Sarah. She looked nervous as I took her from her friends and I told her, "We are all set."
"Really?" she asked, excitedly.
"Really." I told her to pick me up and I'd direct her. "There is one other thing though. This girl wants to know what you are like. So you need to go to the bathroom and masturbate." She looked at me in shock. "You can think about her when you are doing it. Masturbate through your panties, then when you've cum, use your panties to clean yourself up. Then put your panties in this bag, and I will deliver it to her. She'll masturbate all week smelling you."
"Oh, God, I can't do that!" she said.
"You have to," I told her.
She was bright red when she stuffed the plastic bag into my backpack later. I thought that I might even share them with Katherine later on.
I met Sarah late on Saturday morning, and we walked to the bus stop. I couldn't wait until I turned 16 and learned how to drive. "Are you sure about this?" I asked.
Sarah laughed nervously and said, "Yeah, I am." She looked at me for a second then asked, "What would you do if I said I wasn't? Wouldn't this mystery woman be disappointed?"
"Definitely," I said. "But I'd go over and help her get over her misery." She slugged my shoulder and laughed.
While we waited I looked her over. She was wearing tight jeans and a sky blue shirt with a scooped neck, which showed her creamy breasts. She saw me looking her over and asked, "What?"
"I'm just admiring you," I said. "I notice you usually dress to show off your breasts. It looks very nice."
She blushed and said, "I don't have that much, so I want to display them in their best light."
"Well, you've succeeded admirably," I assured her.
Just then the bus pulled up and we got on, sitting towards the back. The bus was mostly empty, so Sarah felt comfortable talking to me. "Will you tell me about this mystery girl?" she asked. "Do you think she'll like me? Do you think I'll like her?"
"I know she'll like you," I said with a grin. "I think you'll like her as well. She's really pretty, and is so easy to be with; it's like she lives life to the fullest. Plus, she knows that this is your first time, and she'll make you very comfortable with what you're going to do."
"What if I chicken out?" she asked.
"She'll understand completely, though she's likely to try and change your mind," I told her.
"What does she look like?" she asked.
"Brown hair, about 5 feet, breast about the size of yours, and she fucks like a mink," I said with a grin.
"Jake," she shrieked, slugging my shoulder again.
I rubbed my shoulder and said, "If you keep that up, I won't have use of my arm, and that would disappoint Katherine too!"
"Her name is Katherine?" Sarah asked.
"Or Cat, depending on her mood," I replied.
"How is this going to work?" she asked.
"Well," I said, "when we walk in, Katherine will be naked. I assume she'll rip your clothes off and bury her face between your legs immediately." She slugged my arm again.
"OK, I actually don't know how this is going to work," I said contritely. "I assume that we'll get there, go in, make some small talk, and eventually get to the part where we are all rolling together on the bed. Speaking of which, you said you wanted me there with you when you did this so that you'd feel more comfortable. Just how much do you want me involved?"
She mulled that over for minute, and then she said, "I guess there are two reasons that I want you there. First, you're someone I know, so it's not like being with a total stranger. Having you there will be like my rock or touchstone; when I get nervous about being with someone I don't know, I can look over at you.
"Second, I know it's silly, but I'm afraid of being a lesbian. I'm worried that if I just have sex with a girl, I'll get all freaked out. That's why I not only want you there to support me, but sometime today I want you to screw me. If I know that I am going to have a dick in me, and that I'll enjoy it, I won't worry about being a lesbian."
"How do you know I'll be able to make you enjoy it?" I asked.
She looked at me sharply and said, "If half of the implications I've heard are true, it won't be an issue."
"I'll do the best I can," I told her. "It's a large sacrifice, but one that I'm willing to make for you."
She slugged me again. "Like you're not dying to get your hands on me!"
"Well, truth be told, I've been hard since this morning thinking of it," I told her. She glanced down at my pants and she saw that I was not kidding.
Sarah glanced around the bus, and with a mischievous smile said, "Show it to me!"
"Here?" I asked.
She nodded.
"You first," I said.
"What do you mean?" she asked, losing a bit of her smile.
"I've been thinking about what your breasts look like since the first time you leaned over in front of me. I've been dreaming of them. I want to see them."
She looked around again and said, "If you've been imagining them for so long, you'll probably be disappointed."
"I doubt it," I said with an expectant smile.
She smirked at me, put her hands behind her back, and wiggled around in that way that all girls seem to know how to do, pulling her bra off without exposing anything. She stuffed it in her bag,, looked around to make sure that no one could see her, and was just about to pull her shirt up when I stopped her.
"Not like that," I said.
She looked at me quizzically and I said, "You wear all these low cut shirts, and I always dream that I can see down them. Just back up and lean over so I can see down your front."
She shrugged, but pushed herself back to the window and leaned over towards me, pulling her shirt away from her front. I looked at her face a moment, then dropped my eyes to see what I had been dreaming of. It turns out that my mind had painted a nearly accurate picture. She had the creamiest breasts I'd ever seen, dusted with freckles and topped with nipples that were the lightest of pinks.
"Oh, god!" I moaned.
"Not what you expected?" she asked, sitting up.
"Better than expected. Perfect even," I replied.
She grinned and then said, "Your turn!"
"After what I've seen, I'm not sure I can pull it out," I said. Now it was me looking around, and when I saw that the coast was still clear, I pulled my zipper down and unsnapped my button. One final glance and I pulled the front of my underwear down as far as I could. My dick sprang out, even harder than I had told Sarah it was.
"Oooh," she said, wrapping her hand around it. "It's nice!" Then, without even a glance around, she dipped down and slurped it into her mouth.
She bobbed up and down for a minute and I groaned, "Looks like you really do like cock!"
"Mmmm hhhhhh", she affirmed.
"I'd love for you to continue for a really long time, but we're coming up on our stop," I said moments later.
She reluctantly pulled away, placing a little kiss on the tip. She patted it and I pulled my underwear back into place. "I always did love sucking cock," she said. "It makes me very popular on dates."
"It doesn't do anything to hurt your popularity with me," I told her with a grin as I zipped up my pants. I stood up, pulled her up by the hand, taking a quick look down her shirt in the process, and we got off of the bus. We walked the three blocks to Katherine's apartment, and walked to the front door. I looked at Sarah and knocked.
Catherine immediately opened the door, as if she was waiting for us. Last time I picked her up at her apartment she had been dressed very young. This time she was dressed in jeans and a button down white dress shirt with a thin white tank top peeking out from underneath. She didn't look 15, but she didn't look more than 17 or 18 either. Given that Sarah was a senior, they appeared close in age.
"Come in," she said, gesturing for us to precede her.
When we walked in, Katherine held out her hand and said, "You must be Sarah. You're even prettier than Jake described you! I'm Cat."
"Hi Cat, pleased to meet you," Sarah said, taking Cat's hand.
Cat pulled Sarah in and gave her a light hug and a peck on the cheek. Then she turned to me and said, "It has been entirely too long since I've seen you!" and she wrapped her arms around my neck and gave me quite a bit more than a peck. When she pulled her tongue out of my mouth, I glanced over at Sarah, who was watching us with a little grin on her face.
Cat glanced at what I was looking at and said, "You'll have to excuse me. I haven't seen Jake in a while, and it's hard to keep my hands off of him."
"Really?" Sarah asked.
Cat glanced at me with a smirk and said, "I'll tell you what. Ask me that again tomorrow. I've got drinks and snacks in the living room. Come and follow me."
We went into the apartment and Cat pointed to a chair for me. She and Sarah sat on the couch and started talking. Very soon, they were chatting like old friends, and I learned quite a bit about both of them. About 45 minutes after we arrived, Sarah said she had to go to the bathroom, and Cat pointed her in the right direction.
While Sarah was gone, Cat looked over at me with a smile and said, "It looks like I'm going to owe you. She's very cute and extremely nice. I don't know if I'm going to be able to stop after just one afternoon."
"That's between the two of you," I said. "I'm just here to chaperon."
"Chaperon my ass!" she exclaimed. Then she dropped to her knees in front of me, and moments later I had the second girl of the day sucking my cock. I had leaned back and closed my eyes, enjoying the sensation, when I heard a gasp in front of me. I opened my eyes and saw Sarah standing there, her hand over her mouth, watching Cat go down on me.
Cat slowly pulled her head back, releasing my cock from her mouth with an audible 'pop', then turned her head and looked right at Sarah. "Jake's a little excited," she said, waving my dick around. "Want to help me take the edge off him?"
It was a good thing that when she asked me earlier, I didn't try and tell Sarah how it was going to go, because this is not how I could have imagined it. Sarah nodded and walked over, dropping to her knees next to Cat. Cat held my cock out to Sarah, who licked it from base to tip before sinking it into her mouth.
"He's got a nice cock, doesn't he?" Cat asked.
When her mouth was empty, Sarah said, "I like it."
While Sarah was answering, Cat recaptured my cock with her mouth. I groaned as she took me deep into her mouth. "Wow, you can deep throat?" Sarah asked.
Cat pulled back out and swung my dick over to Sarah. "Yeah, it just takes a lot of practice to get right. You'll have to find some poor soul willing to let you practice on them."
Sarah pulled off of my cock, then laid her head on my thigh and started licking up and down the side, looking right at Cat. Cat smiled back at her and started doing the same thing from the other side. They moved their heads all around, their tongues bumping into each other, and soon they were locked into a French kiss, right over my cock. Cat continued stroking it in her fist, so I wasn't too disappointed.
Watching them kiss, as well as the feeling of Cat's hand on my cock had me close to the edge. "I'm going to cum," I hissed.
Cat broke the kiss and pushed Sarah's head down to my cock. "Take his cum!" she demanded, "but don't swallow!" Sarah was a little slow, because my first spurt hit her on the cheek, but the rest went right into her hot mouth. While Sarah sucked on the head, Cat kept pumping me with her fist until I was dry.
Sarah pulled her head off of my cock and looked at Cat, her mouth tightly closed. Cat smiled and leaned forward, first licking the string of cum off of Sarah's cheek, then worming her tongue into Sarah's mouth. I watched the two of them kiss, moving my cum back and forth between them, until Sarah pulled back and they both swallowed. Sarah was watching Cat intently as she panted. Then she lunged forward, drilling her tongue into Cat's mouth.
For the next ten minutes I was forgotten as they rolled around on the floor, doing some extremely heavy petting. Cat's hand went under Sarah's shirt in the back, but quickly migrated to the front, squeezing Sarah's delectable breast gently. It wasn't long before Sarah's hand was filled with Cat's breast; apparently Cat wasn't wearing a bra either.
Cat pulled away, groaning as Sarah squeezed her nipple. Then she pushed Sarah away and pulled Sarah's shirt over her head. While Sarah's arms were still tangled in her shirt, Cat pushed her down to the floor and popped Sarah's breast into her mouth. From what I could see, the glance I had on the bus was confirmed; Sarah had remarkable breasts.
Sarah arched her back, and as soon as her hands were free, she grabbed Cat's head, wrapped Cat's hair in her hand, and pulled Cat tight to her breast. Sarah pulled Cat back and forth between them, though Cat had more than her tongue at work. I could tell the exact moment that Cat managed to worm her fingers under Sarah's panties and into her cunt. It was marked by a shriek as Sarah had her first orgasm of the day.
When Sarah came down a little, Cat moved up, her lips inches from Sarah's and asked, "How was your first female induced orgasm?"
"Great," she replied, "but I was 11 at the time, and I was the female."
Cat smiled and moved even closer. "And how do I compare?" she asked.
"Where were you when I was 11?" Sarah asked, then moved in for a long, lingering kiss.
When Sarah broke the kiss, she pulled Cat's shirt off, then pulled off the tank top underneath. She hefted Cat's breasts as she examined them. She glanced up at Cat as she slowly took a nipple in her mouth. I could see that Sarah was savoring the taste and texture as she sucked on her first breast since she was an infant.
Sarah pulled her mouth off and ran her fingers lightly over Cat's breasts. She said, "You know, I've been thinking about doing this for months and months. I was really nervous about if I would be able to do it, and if I was going to like it, but I like it so far. I like you a lot."
Cat smiled and said, "I like you too. But I'd like you better with less clothes on. Come to my bedroom."
Cat pushed herself up and pulled Sarah up into her arms. They kissed again, their breasts mashing together. Then Cat grabbed Sarah around her waist and turned her to face me. "Going to join us?" she asked with a grin.
"Please do!" encouraged Sarah, as if I needed encouragement.
Cat reached over and grasped Sarah's breast and turned to her to kiss her. Then she pulled Sarah's hand and they went into the bedroom. I looked down and saw that my cock was at full extension. I stood up, pulled off my clothes, and followed them to the bedroom.
When I got to the bedroom, Cat was naked on the bed, lying on her back with her head propped against the pillows. Sarah was kneeling between her knees, slowly examining Cat's whole body. From the door I could see Sarah's pale ass sticking up at me. I moved slightly to the side so that I could enjoy the sights in front of me.
Cat looked up at me and winked as Sarah knelt down further. Cat spread her legs wider so that Sarah could take a good look at all her naughty bits. Sarah ran her fingers through Cat's labia, causing her to gasp. Then she looked Cat right in the eye as she swiped her tongue through Cat's juicy pussy.
"Mmmmm," she moaned, as she took another lick. Then she really went to work, digging in deep with her tongue. Cat arched her back, enjoying herself. She smiled up at me and indicated that I should have fun with Sarah. I went around back again, and I could see Sarah's bright pink lips peeking out of her red bush. I had to have some, so I laid on my back and slipped up between her legs.
She must have been quite distracted, because she didn't notice me until I pulled her ass down so that my tongue could spear into her juicy hole. She was delicious, though to be fair, I haven't tasted a pussy yet that I didn't think was delicious. She groaned happily, which set Cat off into her first orgasm. Sarah, however, didn't even slow up; if anything, she began sucking harder. Regretfully, I pulled out from under Sarah. She groaned again, this time in disappointment. The disappointment didn't last too long, however, as I moved up behind her, raised her hips and slipped my cock deep into her.
Sarah actually pulled her mouth off of Cat as she screamed, "Yes!", then she dove back in with renewed vigor. I had come quite recently, so it took me a while to get off. Though they both had as well, they didn't seem to have the same restriction, as both came over and over.
Cat saw me getting close and said, "Cum on her ass!" I looked at her quizzically and she said, "Don't waste it! Cum on her ass!" Never one to object with a naked women writhing beneath me, I pulled out, and with just a few strokes, I spattered my cum over Sarah's ass, in her ass crack, and watched as it dripped down over her engorged pussy.
When I was done, Cat told me to come up to her. I did as she asked, and she pulled Sarah's head up and shoved her at my cock. "Clean him off," she demanded. Sarah did as instructed and soon had my cock shiny and clean.
Meanwhile, Cat moved around behind Sarah and was licking my cum off of Sarah's ass. "Oh!" Sarah cried when she felt Cat's tongue worm over her ass. When she had gotten everything off, she leisurely swiped at Sarah's lips and told her, "When we can get Jake up again, he's going to fuck me, and he's going to cum in my pussy. When he's all done you're going to suck every drop out of me, aren't you?"
"Oh god, yes!" she cried, attacking my cock again, attempting to speed the process. I, however, was not going to be rising quite that quickly.
"I know what will get him up fast," Cat said. "I'll be right back."
Cat left the room, and I pulled Sarah up into a kiss. "Feeling very lezzy?" I asked.
"How could I, with your cock giving me so many orgasms?" she asked. She kissed me again, but I pushed her back so I could get my mouth on those succulent tits. She moaned as I enjoyed myself.
"Oh my god!" Sarah exclaimed, and I looked up at her and saw her looking at the door. There in the doorway stood Cat, with a big fake dick strapped between her legs.
"Move over, Jake! Let someone with a hard on get at her!" she said with a smile.
I moved to the side and watched as Cat stalked towards a frozen Sarah. Cat climbed between Sarah's legs, pushing her back down onto the bed. "Ready to be fucked by a pro?" she asked.
Sarah just nodded, so Cat positioned her dick at Sarah's opening. "Hard or slow?" she asked.
"Hard," Sarah whispered. Cat complied and shoved into Sarah with one thrust. Sarah gasped, then gasped again as Cat quickly pulled out and shoved back in. Catherine was in very good shape, which she amply demonstrated with the jackhammer thrusts she gave to Sarah. I like to think that I can screw a girl, but I would never have the stamina that Cat had.
Sarah quickly came to an orgasm, but Cat offered her the same mercy that she had gotten - none. Sarah appeared to go through 5 or 6 orgasms before she was begging Cat to stop. Cat did, but moved over to Sarah's head and said, "Thank my cock for making you come!" as she pushed Sarah's head towards the plastic dick.
"Thank you so much!" Sarah said as she cleaned the dick off with her tongue.
Then Cat laid down next to Sarah and kissed her. "Mission accomplished," she said, looking over at me. Sarah's eyes lit up as she saw that my cock had risen once again.
"Mmmm," Sarah said, reaching for me.
Cat pulled her hand back, telling Sarah, "You got yours already, this is for me! But if you go to the bathroom, I left you a present on the counter. Try it on and let me see how you look in it. I'll take care of this in the meantime."
Sarah slowly got up and started out of the room, looking back longingly, though I'm not sure if it was me or Cat that she was longing for. As she walked out, Cat pulled me to the center of the bed on my back. She pulled off the strap on and wasted no time straddling me and sinking her hot cunt on my cock.
"How do you think we're doing?" she asked me as she started posting.
"I'm having a good time!" I said.
"And Sarah?" she asked.
"I think she's doing great," I told her.
"Me too," she said. Then her mouth was otherwise occupied with my tongue.
A few minutes later I heard Sarah come back in, and I looked over at her. She was wearing another strap on, this one with a smaller dildo. "Are we going to take turns?" she asked.
"No, look on the nightstand," Cat said.
Sarah walked over and picked up a tube. "What's this for?" she asked.
"That's for lubing up that cock so that you can fuck my ass," Cat replied.
"What?" Sarah exclaimed.
"I love a DP," Cat said.
"A DP?" Sarah asked.
"Double penetration," Cat replied. "I love one cock in my pussy and another in my ass!"
Sarah finally got it, and didn't seem too disgusted by it. She started moving towards Cat, who said, "Make sure you lube up your cock well." Sarah complied, slathering on plenty of gel from the tube.
Cat slowed down her movements until she was just making little thrusts as Sarah climbed between our legs. "Slow or hard?" Sarah asked.
Cat smiled over her shoulder and said, "Not slow, but not too hard."
I felt Sarah adjusting position, then I felt the dildo pushing against my cock through the wall of Cat's pussy. "Yessssss!" Cat hissed as Sarah pushed into her in one long, slow thrust, eventually pressing her bush against Cat's ass. Sarah and I just stayed there, unmoving, as Cat adjusted, moving her hips just slightly.
Cat leaned back, pulling Sarah to her for a kiss. I took the opportunity as she presented her breast to me and sucked on her sensitive nipple. She hissed into Sarah's mouth and then said, "OK now, both of you do me!"
It took a few minutes for Sarah and me to work out a rhythm that worked, but by the time we did, Cat was flopping around between us, whipping her head around and moaning. Sarah leaned over Cat's back, pushing her chest against me, and she leaned her head around Cat and kissed me hard on my lips. "Thank you for this," she said with a smile, then she got back onto her knees and asked, "Slow or hard?"
"Hard, dammit, give it to me hard!" Cat screamed. Sarah grabbed Cat's hips and started pounding into her, pulling her back and shoving her forward with each stroke. I just stopped moving and went along for the ride.
I took the opportunity to watch the two of them, Cat with her eyes glazed in lust, sweaty and panting, clearly unable to put even a single coherent thought together, and Sarah, her eyes clear with purpose, shifting her glance between the spot where they were joined, the back of Cat's head, and my face. She smiled at me, and between the sexy pair of them and the tight feeling of Cat's pussy wrapped around my cock, I was soon shooting my load deep into Cat's pussy.
"Yes!" screamed Cat as she felt my cock pulse. "Give me all your cum!"
I did as she asked, and I felt Sarah speeding her thrusts. In just a minute I felt Cat squeezing against my shrinking cock as she came yet again. "No more!" she groaned to Sarah, who seemed quite content to keep pounding.
Sarah slowed down, but Cat pushed her back and out of her. Cat flopped off of me and onto her back, trying to get her breath. "Get that off of her!" she told me, pointing to the strap on Sarah proudly wore. I took a deep breath and complied, helping Sarah remove the straps.
"Now get his cum out of me," Cat told Sarah. Sarah started moving between Cat's legs, but Cat said, "No, I want a chance at you, too!"
I realized that Cat had shown remarkable restraint, as this was the first time she was going to get a taste of Sarah. She pulled Sarah's legs over her head, and I watched the two of them eat each other. Sarah licked all around Cat's pussy, picking up the cum that was starting to drain out, before digging her tongue in to scoop out as much as she could. Cat, on the other hand, dove right in, as if she wanted to bury her head in Sarah.
They continued for a few minutes, until Cat's expert tongue brought Sarah to an orgasm. Then Cat flipped them over so that she was on top. She went up on her knees over Sarah's head and told her, "Watch this!" She then started squeezing her stomach, and soon little globs of cum started dripping out into Sarah's eager mouth.
"Get over here," Cat demanded of me. "I want a taste, too!" I moved over to her and she slurped my shrunken cock into her mouth, cleaning all of the remaining cum off. My cock barely twitched; I was completely spent.
When Sarah had gotten all that she was going to get, Cat pushed me away and dropped down to lie next to Sarah. "Go make us a snack!" she ordered me.
"Yes, Mistress!" I replied.
"You wish!" she laughed.
"No, you do," I said, smiling.
I walked out and went to the bathroom where I cleaned myself up a bit. Then I went to the kitchen and gathered some fruit and drinks and carried it back into Cat's bedroom. When I returned, they were both still snuggling together, talking quietly.
They sat up, and Cat groaned. "Oh, god, I am going to be so sore tomorrow. Especially my ass!"
"Oh, I'm sorry," Sarah said sounding worried. "Was I too hard?"
"Yes," Cat said, leaning over to kiss her. "And I loved every second of it. All day tomorrow, every time I move around in my seat, I'm going to be thinking of Sexy Sarah and how she pounded me so good!"
Sarah smiled and took a bite of her fruit. When we were done with our snack, Cat took Sarah into the shower while I cleaned up a little. I got dressed and waited in the living room, listening to the giggling coming from the next room. A while later, Sarah came out looking as fresh as when we arrived. I don't know how I looked, but I didn't feel like I looked that fresh.
Cat came over to me and kissed me deeply. "I definitely owe you one, and I plan to pay up soon!"
Sarah heard just a bit of this, and her face clouded up. "Pay?" she asked.
Cat laughed and caressed Sarah's face. "Oh, lovely Sarah. When Jake called me and I agreed to this, he said he'd owe me one. After today's session, I definitely owe him one, and I was just promising to pay him back soon."
Sarah smiled and kissed Cat. "Maybe I can help you pay him back," she said brightly.
"Oh, we'll see," Cat said with a smile. "That's definitely an advanced lesson." I laughed, though Sarah looked confused.
We took our leave and headed back to the bus stop. Sarah slipped her hand into mine as we walked along. "I really do want to thank you, Jake," she said. "This was better than I imagined!"
"So you're ready to go over to the dark side?" I asked with a smile.
"No, but I am now a confirmed bisexual!" she replied.
We walked along a little longer and she asked quietly, "Do you mind if I see Cat again?"
"Without me?" I shrieked theatrically.
She slugged my arm again. "Stop teasing," she demanded. "I really like her, and she said she'd be willing to see me again. Would you be upset?"
"Not if you took pictures for me," I said grinning, then held up my hand to stop her from slugging my arm again. "Really, I don't mind. And if you ever feel like you're leaning too far that way, feel free to ask me to bring you back."
She smiled and pulled me in for a kiss. She was mostly lost in her thoughts on her way home, but she gave me another big kiss and thanked me again just before we went our own ways.
Another successful fantasy fulfilled. And I was as well.