How I Blackmailed My Sister
Chapter Two
"Paying the Piper"
Written by TVM
Copyright © 2005
Disclaimer: This story is purely fantasy. The events portrayed in this series (although I wish) never happened. Any reposting or archiving without written permission is an infringement on the copyright of this series. So in other words You damn well better ask before you steal it.
Feedback: Every author in his or her own way makes it a point to ask for feedback when posting a story, well me I don't usually. But there are several reasons as to why a reader should consider taking the time to give it. The simple fact is that giving some form of feedback is truly the most important thing a reader can do after reading and enjoying a story. Hopefully in the process providing that author with at least one viable reason as to what you liked about the story. This small amount of time spent will no doubt inspire the author to write more and possibly at a quicker pace, knowing that they have a fan base who are waiting on their next works. So thanks for the feedback and please keep it comin.
Summary: In ALL NEW 2nd episode of 'How I Blackmailed My Sister', we open with Molly informing her older sister, Holly, exactly what she has to do to keep their Mom and Dad from seeing the tape of Holly's orgy just minutes before. Not quite able to believe Molly really wants to fuck her, Holly refuses and offers up an interesting compromise. One which will still let Molly fulfill most of her fantasies. But it doesn't involve Holly directly, will Molly still go for it?
Story Codes: ff, phone sex
"YOU SNEAKY LITTLE BITCH!" Holly screamed, as her eyes filled with rage, "Your gonna fucking pay for this."
"That's what you get for treating me like shit." I said, my stomach doing flip flops by now. "It's payback time, sissy."
"I swear, if you don't give me that tape right now, I'm gonna BEAT YOUR ASS." Holly growled getting louder with each word. She moved towards me slowly. Then suddenly she lunged over the bed barely missing me, as I backed out of the way in the nick of time.
"Oops, missed me by that much." I laughing nervously, jumping backwards into the bathroom door.
Suddenly, I knew exactly what to do. I backed into the bathroom, and pulled off the necklace. Making sure Holly saw it as she came charging into the room.
"Come here you little bitch and take your beating like a woman." She screamed, now running towards the bathroom door. I gripped Mom's necklace tight around my fingers.
"You come near me and I'll drop it." I said, now swinging the necklace over the toilet as Holly stopped at the door.
"What the hell?"
"Yeh, it's Mom's prize necklace." I said.
"OH, your gonna get it so bad you little whore." Holly said thru clenched teeth with her hands clenched into fists.
"Your calling me a whore." I said looking at her in disbelief," your the slut that just fucked another girl, you fuckin carpet muncher."
Holly started towards me again. "I swear to god I'll drop it bitch, BACK OFF." I screamed.
"Ok, ok." She said putting up her hands and trying to reason with me, " just don't drop it."
"I won't if you do what I say."
"What do you want?" Holly asked.
She seemed to calm down a lot after that. Her hands where no longer clenched into fists. She was standing on the other side of the room still. Which gave me some peace of mind.
"It's very simple big sister." I started, "Your gonna be my slave for the rest of the weekend."
"Do what?" Holly asked, with a "I don't believe this bullshit" look on her face.
"You heard me," I said now getting more confidence, "you are my slave for the rest of the weekend."
"If you think I'm gonna wait on you hand and foot until Mom and Dad get back your psycho." Holly said.
"Considering the circumstances Holly, I don't think you have much of a choice." I stated matter of factly.
"Well...." My big tough sister stammered, "what exactly will I have to do."
"Everything I tell you to slut." I said, now confident I had her in the palm of my hand. I pulled the neckalce back over my head, once again letting it fall between my tits.
"IF YOU EVER CALL ME THAT AGAIN I SWEAR ON MY LIFE" She screamed at the top of her lungs, "I'LL KICK YOUR ASS FROM HERE TO HELL AND BACK."
I jumped back for a moment, again pulling the necklace up from under the shirt. Showing it to her and smiling victoriously.
"Yeh I see it." Holly said, "and I don't care, I'm not a slut."
"Ok. Ok. Sorry." I said giggling, "you obviously prefer to be called a whore."
"Sis your asking for it." She said and I knew if I didn't stop she was gonna do a number on me.
"Will you just fuckin tell me what exactly I have to do, so you will give me that tape." Holly asked trying to sound pathetic.
"Ok." I said, "it's nothing major I just want you to show me a few things."
"Like what?" she asked continuing on before I had a chance to respond, "my porno collection."
I started laughing at that comment. Did she honestly think I would have gone to all the trouble to video tape her doing her boyfriend and another girl if all I wanted was to look at her porno collection. She must have still been thinking about Megan.
"Sis are you stupid?" I asked, "Do you think I would go to all this trouble just to see some magazine, that I've already seen by the way."
"Well I dunno." She replied sounding flabbergasted.
"What I want is simple." I said moving towards her slowly now, "I want you sis."
"You want me to what?" She asked looking confused.
"I want you to..." I said pausing for dramatic effect, "to show me what it's like to fuck another girl."
Holly's eyes bugged out of her head as she tried to comprehend what I had just said. She was having trouble believing it I guess. Because she stood there for the longest time before she said anything at all. Just looking dumbfounded.
I moved my hands to the sides of her shoulders and began to rub them up and down slowly.
"You ok sis?" I asked.
"Are.... you.....kidding?" She asked, stuttering badly through the shock of it.
"No sis I'm not." I said, moving her hair out of her face now.
"You know that's pretty fucking sick." Holly said just now recovering.
"Well considering what I just watched you do to Will and Megan," I started, "and what they did to you. I don't know why in the hell it would matter to you."
"Because your my fucking sister that's why."
"Oh big fucking deal." I said trying to act non-chalant, "Jessica Brewer's been doing her little sister since she was 12."
"Your kidding?" Holly asked, obviously surprised.
"No, she was bragging about it the last time she slept over here. I told Holly, "she's actually proud of it, I think."
"Shit." Holly said still sorta in shock, "but that still don't change my opinion."
"Look, Holly you really don't have much of a choice." I said pushing her back against the wall and staring her right in the eyes, "cause if you don't, I know a great movie Mom and Dad will wanna watch when they get back."
Holly looked at me for the longest time. Trying to figure a way out of this little predicament. Finally after a long couple of moments she said, "what about if I get Megan to show you, will that make you happy."
I moved back letting her free from the wall and thought about it for a second. Megan was so hot, that idea really started to turn me on. Not only that, she had done it plenty before I was willing to bet.
"Ok, sis I can live with that." I said as she breathed a sigh of relief, "but you gotta watch or it's no deal."
"Now come on Molly...." She complained.
"No you, no deal." I said smiling devilishly, "and you know what that means."
"Ok, you conniving little cunt you got your way." She said glaring at me with her hands once again clenched into fists at her sides, "I'll fuckin watch."
"Good girl." I said moving close to her and patting my sister on the head like a puppy.
"Fuck you." She barked at me. Slapping my hand away and turning to leave the room.
"Uh, sis." I said, "I think you forgot a little something."
"What?" She asked spinning around suddenly.
"I want you to call Megan and set it up right now." I said holding up the cordless phone for her to take. She snatched it from my hand and glared at me one more time. Before punching the phone number into the phone and waiting for an answer.
Megan answered and they chatted for a few minutes as Holly sat down on my bed and made herself at home. That is until, I reminded her of the purpose for the phone call. When I motioned for her to get on with it, she reluctantly went into what had happened and what she needed Megan to do.
"Tell her if she doesn't wanna do it it's ok." I said whispering into my sister's ear, "of course she is on that tape too you know."
"Ok, Ok, shut the fuck up." Holly said covering up the phone for a split second.
"Oh, god thank you I owe you a big, big, big favor." Holly said breathing a sigh of relief, "Oh really you do huh...."
Holly looked straight at me with an evil grin on her face and said "ok little sister you wanna be a lesbian, then here talk to one."
The phone was shoved into my hand in a matter of seconds before I could do or say anything. I gradually moved the phone to my ear, becoming more nervous by the second.
"Hey there sexy." I heard Megan say as the phone reached my ear.
"Hey."
"So your curious about what's it's like to be with another girl huh?" Megan asked me in a sexy voice.
"Uh yeh kinda." I said still taken aback by all that had happened tonight.
"Well are you or aren't you?" Megan asked sounding like I was getting on her nerves, "your sister just told me how hot you are to fuck another girl."
"Yeh I am...I mean I want to." I said beginning to recover, "and I wanna fuck you."
"Awwwww, fuck girl your making me hot all over again." Megan moaned lightly into the phone.
"Oh yeh me too, my pussy is on fire and Holly won't help me out." I said rubbing the front my cum soaked shorts, "would you like to fuck my virgin pussy."
"Uh yeh I'll show you how good a girl can make you feel." She moaned to me, "your a hot little thing too you know that."
"OH, you think I'm sexy?" I asked pushing Holly off my bed and sitting down, "I watched that video and came twice just watching you and Holly fuck. I wanted to be there so bad."
"Oh, god your making me hot you little tease." Megan said giggling thru another moan, "Why don't you get rid of Holly and we'll talk for a while, so I can give maybe give you a little one on one instruction, ok?."
"Well ok." I said, "But when you come over Holly has to watch."
"Of course, I wouldn't want it any other way." Megan cooed.
I told Megan to hold on and motioned for Holly to leave. Which she did but only reluctantly it appeared. She was getting really turned on listening to us, by the looks of it. Her nipples were hard and she was listening very intently to our conversation.
"Ok, I got rid of Holly now what were you saying?"
"I was gonna tell you how much I am tempted to drive over there right now and give you a lesson you'll never forget." Megan said.
"Oh god girl I wish you would," I said. "I'm hotter now than I've ever been."
"Oh I'm rubbing my pussy just thinking about you and your sweet cum on my lips." Megan said as my hands slipped down under my shorts, and I layed back on the bed.
"MMMMMM, fuck girl tell me more." I said getting hotter by the second.
"Oh I would lick it all off for you." She said moaning a little herself, "then suck your little virgin clit hard again."
"Uh huh," I said stroking my hot little pussy slowly now.
"I can taste you now, your better than candy baby." She moaned for me, "my soft lips are on your clit suckin harder and harder."
"Oh god fuck yes I can feel it so good." I moaned back more intensely, now rubbing my clit relentlessly.
"OOOOOOOHHHHHHHH shit I'm gonna cum." Megan moaned, "Cum for me baby, cum with me"
"Yeh Fuckin yes suck my clit, I'm cummin for you." I moaned out loud.
That was the last words spoken for a while. The conversation then turned into a serious of moans and grunts as we both came. My orgasm was the most intense of my entire life. I tensed up at first then I began to jerk as it peaked and it's wonderful hold surged through my body time and again.
"Oh shit, I've never cum that hard doing it myself." Megan panted after a minute or so of heavy breathing.
"Man I know it was so good for me too." I said, my hole body tingling from the afterglow, "will you please come over?"
"I wish I could but Will was my ride." She said sounding a little sad, "but tommorrow night I promise you, I will."
"Really?" I asked getting excited again just thinking about it.
"Hell yeah, and I'll show you exactly what you been missing out on all this time." Megan said sounding more excited herself.
We talked for a minute or two more before we hung up. We made plans to meet the next day at the mall, and come back to my house for a little "studying".
I hung up the phone and swung my legs over the side of the bed, getting ready to leave the room. When I noticed a shadow in the light below my door.
"That horny little bitch." I said knowing it was Holly eavsedropping at the door.
I slipped off my bed, mumbling quitely. Pretending I was still talking to Megan. I tip toed to my bedroom door, then all in one motion I grabbed the knob, twisted it and jerked it open.
"WOW SHIT." Holly screamed as she feel into my room like a ton of bricks.
"You nosey fuckin cunt." I said.
"Sounds like you and Megan had a fun time." She giggled, making me blush.
"Yeh we did." I said.
"So you guys are gonna fuck huh?" She asked obviously curious to know all the datails.
"Yeh." I said sitting down beside my sister, "we're gonna meet at the mall tommorrow. Then we're gonna come back here and have a little fun."
"Oh really?" she asked teasingly.
"Yeh and I bet you can't wait." I said, "I know you were listening at the door and probabely working your hot little pussy too."
"Yeh so." She said, sounding a little angry.
"Well five minutes ago you wouldn't fuck me, but now your getting all hot and bothered listening to me and your girlfriend phone fuck."
"I was actually looking for something." She said.
"Yeh what?" I asked.
"Ummmmm, my cap pen." She stammered.
"HAAA bullshit." I replied, "you were listening to us and it got you off...admit it"
"I wasn't listening and you can't prove it." She said standing up and getting ready to leave.
"Fine then, don't admit it BITCH" I screamed, "But I tell you this...."
"What?" She asked spinning around.
"Tommorrow night." I started, "me and you are gonna fuck."
"Look Molly I already told you I wouldn't do it." She said with a lot less resistents in her voice.
"Yeh whatever Holly." I said, "but you know what I think? You want it, I think you like the idea of me forcing you to do it."
"God you are so perverted." She said turning to leave again.
"HOLLY!" I screamed.
As she turned around I pulled my shirt over my head and pushed my cum soaked shorts to the floor. Kicking them in the air at Holly, who caught them and looked at me intently. I was now standing completely naked in front of my sister. She stood there for what seemed like forever before she blinked. But finally she half smiled and walked away, still with my shorts in her hands.
"Good night sis" She said as I heard her door slam.
To be Continued...
Incredible! It's written in such a way that makes it so believable. I feel like I'm there! Can't wait to get to the next part.