Note: This story was dynamically reformatted for online reading convenience.
 
 My Sisters and Me by Drew

   There wasn't much more to Frank's tale.  The police never found any
other hard evidence that Paco had abducted those girls, and the story later
became an urban legend around the town.  Frank moved away shortly after the
disappearances and never looked back.  As far as he knew, Paco, nor any of
the girls, were ever found.  Nonetheless, the story was going to stick with
me, for obvious reasons.

   The group of us piled into a taxi van and headed into town.  There were
a couple of bars that seemed to be bumping, with long lines outside.  We
got out at one of them and got in the back of the line.

   "This bloooows," Kenzie groaned, after about 20 minutes of not moving.
"They're not letting anyone in!"

   "I know.  Maybe we SHOULD have left at 9PM!" Maddy said, giving her big
sister an accusatory look.

   "Oh, shut it.  Frank's story was prolly the most fun we'll have
tonight." Katie said.

   "It was creepy!" Ara said.

   "Yeah, seems like it actually DID happen too!  There's some old articles
when you Google search it," Kelly said.

   "What do you guys say we lean into the creepiness?" Katie asked.

   "What?"

   "Let's ditch this tourist club, we're not getting in, anyway!  I'm sure
we can find a dive bar down the road."

   "But we got all dressed up," Kenzie protested.

   "Who cares?  We either show off our outfits to some old local drunks or
we stand out here all night getting more and more sober," Katie said.

   "I'm down for a dive bar," Jordan said.  And the others agreed.  The
swaying factor was Katie's line about becoming more sober.

   We began walking down the main drag of town, which was just one street,
about 2 miles long.  We branched off one the side-roads and found our way
into a poorly lit neighborhood.  Wasn't long before we found what Katie was
looking for.

   The building was an old piece of shit.  It was built of weathered bricks
and had a sign out front that read "Mike's." The sign wasn't even lit.  We
bashed through the front door and it felt like we were a group of summer
interns, their first day on the job.  All eyes were instantly on us,
judging us, checking out the girls, and ultimately deciding that we weren't
worth the hassle.

   There were more people in the bar than I would've initially thought. 
Maybe 15 to 20.  Mostly older men, but there were a few women that looked
rough around the edges and never grew out of their high school looks.  We
were clearly out of place, even without being overly dressed.  Luckily, I
still had a decent buzz going.

   "Clubs are over on Main," The bartender grumbled.  He was a tall, fat
man, with a scraggly, grey beard.

   "Couldn't get in, I'll take a Miller draft please," Katie said with her
alluring confidence.

   "Ditto." Kelly said.

   The bartender looked curiously at the girls before pouring their beers.
The rest of us ordered, and he didn't bother to check any of our IDs
(shocking, I know.) We found a table and began drinking up, not saying
much, but observing the crowd.  They weren't very interesting.  They played
some pool, played some darts, argued amongst each other, and told some
stories of their youth that they had probably told fifty times before.

   "OH MY GOD, wait till you guys see what's over there!" Maddy said
excitedly when she came back from using the restroom.

   "What?!"

   "You gotta go see it, I'm not spoiling it!"

   "Alright, I gotta see this," Katie said.  She strolled over to the back
hallway where the bathrooms were located.  She took her time and wasn't
overly obvious before she came back to her seat with her eyes wide.  She,
too, didn't ruin the surprise.

   One by one we walked over there, and by now, some of the patrons had
noticed what we were doing.  But I had had a couple more beers in me and
really didn't give a shit.  I walked over and saw it.  A black leather
plague doctor mask hanging on the wall.

   "That thing's scary A-F!" Ara said once all of us had seen it.

   "Why would they have that on the wall?!" Kelly asked.  "You think
that's....the actual one Paco wore?"

   "Okay, one, there's no actual evidence it was Paco," Jordan began.  The
girls looked at him as if he were a dumbass.  "What?!  There's not!  Yeah,
he was perving on his sisters and prolly knew how bad that looked, so he
skipped town.  I'm sure they searched the fuck out of his stuff, they
would've found something on the missing girls."

   "Not if he hid all that evidence somewhere else...or you know...buried
it with the girls." Kelly said.

   "Then why did he leave the tape recordings of his sisters?" Jordan
asked. I really wanted this topic to be dropped.

   "I don't know, why DID he?  Whether he kidnapped those girls or not, it
was a stupid thing to leave behind.  Not sure why leaving them makes him
more innocent?" Katie asked.

   "That's my point, it WAS stupid.  Why was he so careful with everything
else, but so careless with the videos?  I think when he found out the real
plague doctor planted those pictures at the school, he panicked and ran
away cause he knew the cops would come back after him.  And he knew what
they would find.  It wasn't worth going back to his place to grab the tapes
and risk getting caught."

   "You've thought a lot about this, huh, Jordan?" Kenzie laughed.

   "Yeah, weirdo," Kelly laughed as well.  "What do you think, Drew?" I
almost spilled my beer.

   "I errr...I don't know.  He prolly did it.  I guess?  Like Katie said
it's usually fam -"

   I was interrupted by the bar door opening, and an older man with long
black hair, tan skin, and chiseled features came slowly walking in.

   "WHAT THE FUCK?!" Maddy whispered excitedly.  "That's him!"

   "Shut up, Mads, no it's not," Katie laughed.

   "Yeah it is, that's him!"

   "You're being racist, Maddy," Katie continued to giggle.

   The man looked around the bar before his dark eyes lingered on the girls
at our table - particularly the ones with black hair.  He then moved past
them, and took a seat at the bar.  The others didn't pay him much
attention.

   "We gotta get the fuck out of here!" Maddy said, hysterically.  It
actually was pretty funny now.

   "Mads, relax!" Katie said.  "You really think all these other people
would just be chilling here if that was him?"

   "They all forgot about it!  You heard Frank!"

   "They clearly didn't, with that plague mask over there," Kelly said.

   "Yeah Mads, look around," Katie said.  "these people have all been
coming to this bar since `Nam.  These are the leftovers from that era."

   "Whattever, this place gives me the heeby jeebies.  Can we go back to
the resort?" Maddy pleaded.

   "Agreed, yeah...I don't know if this is all some elaborate prank your
grandpa's pulling or what, but as a girl who prolly fits pretty damn close
to how those kidnapped girls looked, I'd feel safer at the resort," Ara
said.  She seemed genuinely nervous, for the first time since I'd met her.
And I felt extra guilty, given the fact that I had already creeped on her
changing.  Thank GOD I deleted that video.

   "Alright, we should all start heading back.  Definitely don't think you
guys should be going alone," I said, standing up from my chair.

   "Boooo, you guys are lame," Katie said.  But she stood up as well.

   We all gathered our things and made our way to the door.  I held it open
for the girls and Jordan.  I don't know why I did it, but I looked back
into the bar at the tanned, black-haired man.  His coal eyes stared back at
me.



   **********

   Once we got back to the hotel, and in the comfort of familiar faces, it
was time to let loose.  The hotel bar remained open, though most of the
wedding crowd had dispersed.  Jim and Kevin were still out, enjoying a
nightcap.  Emily's bridesmaids were still out and about as well, though
Emily herself, along with Amira, seemed to have called it a night.

   Nonetheless, our group was the rowdiest.  The spookiness of the night
had gotten all of us in an excited, playful mood.  Jordan and Kenzie had
turned their flirting dial up full notch, and I had zero doubt they were
going to hook up tonight.  They were handsy, making out in public, and even
tugging on one another's clothes.  Two cats in heat.

   "Will you two just go and get it over with already?!" Katie asked,
loudly.

   The couple ignored her.

   "Uggghhhh they're insufferable," Kelly groaned.

   "Tell me about it," I said.

   "Let's just let them be," Katie started.  "They'll eventually find
themselves up in one of our rooms and bang it out.  Then it'll be over
with."

   "Yeah, good plan." Kelly said.  A few months ago, she absolutely did not
want her brother hooking up with Kenzie.  But now, she had given up trying
to fight off the inevitable.  Katie, Kelly, and I got up and walked out to
the pool area with our drinks.

   Maddy and Ara were all over the place.  They were toasted.  Dancing,
singing karaoke (poorly), and causing a scene.  Jim and Kevin were laughing
at them.  Emily's bridesmaids looked more annoyed.  Even Michaela, who had
been drunk this entire trip.

   I turned on the gas fireplace out by the pool and hooked my phone up to
the Bluetooth speakers.  Kelly snuggled up right next to me, and began
subtly caressing my arm.  I caught Katie's grin and raised eyebrows out of
the corner of my eye.  My arm hooked around Kelly's waist, and my hand
rested on her thigh.

   Katie sat down opposite us.  I'm not sure if she was trying to get
attention, or maybe just teasing me and entertaining herself while Kelly
was turned away, but she sat with her legs spread open showing off a TON of
thigh.  To the point I saw her light panties pop into a view a few times.
She also "dropped" her phone and bent over slowly, exposing her cleavage. I
was starting to get horny.  But Kelly didn't want to start making out in
front of her friend.  I actually think she was beginning to get annoyed by
the fact that Katie was still here.  She let out a tiny sigh, and got up to
use the restroom.

   "You just gonna third-wheel us all night?" I said to my sister once
Kelly was gone.

   "Is that what I'm doing?" She said, unbothered.  I just rolled my eyes
at her.  "That why you can't take your eyes off me?"

   I didn't respond, and the silence was broken by the younger girls.

   "You guys!" Maddy said excitedly.  "Let's go spy on Kenzie and Jordan!"

   "Oh, leave them alone.  Like I said, once they hook up they'll stop
acting like this.  But if you interrupt it..." Katie said.

   "Drew?!" Ara asked, ignoring Katie.

   I didn't have any interest in seeing what Jordan and Kenzie were up to.
I wanted to get laid tonight.  Kelly came back out.

   "Kelly!  We're gonna go creep on your brother!" Maddy said.

   "Eww!" Kelly said.  "I don't wanna see that," she giggled.

   "C'mon!  It'll be funny!" Maddy said.

   Kelly looked at me and smiled.  "Drew?  You gonna go up there?" Her
facial expression filled in the unsaid words.  Perhaps we can sneak off on
our own after?

   "Sure," I said.  "Let's go.

   "Nice!" Ara and Maddy said.  Katie gave me a curious smirk, but got up
herself to follow us over to the elevator.  We rode up to Jordan and I's
room.  But as it turned out, we didn't have to do any creeping.

   "HAHAHAHAHA!" There was cackling as soon as the elevator door opened.

   "Jordan!!!" Kenzie's screams could be heard.  "Come back!"

   Jordan came sprinting down the hallway wearing only boxer briefs and
swinging around material in his hand.

   "What the - !" Katie blurted out.

   "Jordan!  Gross!!" Kelly said as she covered her eyes.  "Put some
clothes on!"

   "THE PLAGUE DOCTOR IS BAAAACK!!!!!" Jordan cried out.  And I realized
what was in his hand.  He held Kenzie's underwear up with pride and burst
out laughing.  He had drawn a large smiley face on them.

   "OHHHH MY GOD!!!" Maddy was laughing, but put her hand over her mouth in
shock.

   "Jordan!  Those are expensive!" Kelly scolded him.

   "She don't care!" he replied.

   "KENZ!!!!" Ara shrieked.

   Kenzie had sprinted out of the hotel room into the hallway after Jordan.
And she was buck ass naked!

   "AHHH!" She yelped when she saw the crowd, but she didn't bother to
cover anything.  She ran right toward us, her tiny tits barely moved at
all. She ran up to Jordan as he held her panties above his head.  Kenzie
had zero shame, as she jumped up and down, tits and cooch on show, trying
to steal them back.  Eventually, she gave up, and bent over laughing, and
to catch her breath.  She finally draped her arms over her privates.

   All the commotion had caused some neighboring doors to open.  Emily was
the first one.  She peaked her head out and saw the ridiculous scene.  "Oh
my God!" She said.  She was somewhat annoyed, somewhat amused.  "Can you
guys take this elsewhere?"

   "Emily, what is it!?" I heard Brian's excited voice from behind her.

   "Nothing Brian!" Emily screamed out.  "Go back to bed!"

   "I wanna see what's - whoah!!!" Brian snuck his head out and got a full
view of Jordan holding the smiley faced underwear and Kenzie cowering
beside him.  Brian looked her up and down before Emily forced him back into
the room.

   "Goodnight, guys!" She said, slamming the door.

   On the other side, Alex had opened her door and was staring at us.  Once
we noticed her, she said "Oh!  Errr sorry!" and shut the door quickly. 
THANK GOD Nancy hadn't come out.  Jordan gave Kenzie her underwear back and
she quickly slipped them back on in front of us - showing us her cute
little ass in the process.

   "Guys, we gotta get out of this hallway," I said.

   "Night swim!?" Jordan proposed.

   "Yeah!" Ara and Maddy said.  The rest of us agreed to partake.  In
celebration, Ara whisked Kenzie's panties back down to her ankles.  For the
third time in 24 hours, I got a good look her Kenzie's freckled box.  She
groaned and rolled her eyes at her friend, before nonchalantly pulling her
underwear back up.

   The girls went their separate ways to get their swimsuits.  I guess
Kenzie must have stopped at the store at some point to buy another pair of
bikini bottoms.  Jordan and I went back to our room.  The place was a mess.
There were drinks and food all over the place from earlier.  Sheets on the
floor.

   "Well?" I asked him as I tied up my swim trunks.

   "Oh yeah," a proud grin emerged on his face.  "She's a wild one."

   "I bet," I chuckled.

   We finished getting ready and made our way down to the pool.  Katie and
Kelly followed, showing off their curves in their bikinis.  The four of us
swam and continued to drink before the rest of the girls showed up.  They
had towels wrapped around themselves.

   "Thought we'd liven this party up!" Maddy exclaimed.

   "With a little bit of....SKINNY dipping!!" Kenzie announced, and the
trio of girls laughed.

   Jordan and I got excited.  "Seriously?!" I asked.

   "They're definitely wearing their bikinis under that," Kelly said.

   "Yeah calm down, doofus.  They're not actually gonna do it," Katie
scoffed.

   "Oh yeah?!" Maddy asked her older sister.  She reached her hands under
her robe and finagled her bikini bottoms down to her ankles.  Her eyes went
wide and her mouth agape wearing a "I can't believe we're doing this!"
expression as she looked at her friends - who followed suit.

   Maddy, Kenzie, and Ara then all reached up under the upper portion of
the robes and untied their tops.  They tossed them to the ground.

   "We seriously doing this!?" Ara asked with excitement.

   "Yup!" Kenzie said.

   God I could kiss Frank for telling us his tale earlier and getting these
three hotties in such unusual (well, not unusual for Kenzie) frisky moods.

   With their bikinis on the cement, the girls began counting down.

   "THREEEE........TWO......" They began untying their robes. 
".....ONE!!!!!!!!!!!"

   All three of them opened the robes and tossed them aside, but....ARA was
the only one naked!  She screamed in shock as she saw her friends had
tricked her.  Her dark nips and smooth pubic region were briefly exposed,
before she shot her hands to cover up.

   "NICE!!!" Jordan and I shouted triumphantly.

   "AHAHAHA!!" Maddy and Kenzie cackled and jumped into the pool in their
"backup" bikinis.

   Ara followed suit, jumping nude into the water.  She probably should
have grabbed her bikini first, but I guess she figured this was the
quickest way to cover up.

   "You guys!  Oh my God!!" Ara yelled at her friends when she resurfaced.

   "Shouldn't have pulled my underwear down!" Kenzie laughed.

   "That didn't even bother you!" Ara argued.

   "ARA'S NAKEY, ARA'S NAKEY!!!!!" Maddy started to drunkenly chant.

   "Stop!" Ara treaded water with fear on her face as she shot some looks
over at Jordan and I.  We couldn't really see anything while she was in the
pool.  A lot of dark, murky, flesh.  But that didn't stop us from wearing
big, shit-eating grins on our faces.

   "God, y'all are loud!" Jim and Kevin strolled out on the pool deck.  I
had no idea they were still awake.  Michaela, Allison, and the other
bridesmaids were behind them.

   "Seriously!" Ara muttered under her breath.  She began splashing her
friends.

   Jim spotted the three bikinis on the ground.  "Damn, ain't it a bit cold
out for swimming buck nekkid?" He and Kevin sat down on some of the pool
chairs and lit up cigars.  The other women sat down near them.

   "Ask Ara," Maddy said, and burst out giggling.  Ara splashed her again.

   "It IS getting cold out here, now that I think of it," I said,
mischievously.  Jordan grinned at me, with understanding.  I swam over to
the ladder and climbed out.  He, and then Katie and Kelly, climbed out
after me.

   "Awww c'mon girls, didn't have the cajones to take your suits off?!"
Kevin asked with disappointment as he checked out Kelly.

   "No cajones here, Kev," Katie said, pointing to her groin.  She and her
friend wrapped themselves up in towels and relaxed by the pool fire.

   "Ya know, that DOES look tempting!" Kenzie said.

   "Ohmygod, you guys don't!  Thought it was just Drew and Jordan!" Ara
pleaded.

   But Kenzie didn't listen.  She climbed out of the pool to the boos of
the men and waltzed over to the fire.

   "Well, there's three bikinis out here and only two of ya left in there.
Not sure how that works out," Jim said.

   "They're just a bunch of teases!" Michaela said.

   Maddy hung out in the water with Ara for a bit, but you could tell both
of them were getting cold.  They started to shiver.

   "Sorry, Ara!" Maddy said.

   "Maddy don't!  Please?!" Ara continued to beg.

   "Just do it quick, it's dark out, they won't see much," Maddy said, and
she pulled herself up out of the water, put her robe back on, and joined
Kenzie by the fire.

   Jim and Kevin didn't say much when Maddy got out.  Not really kosher to
voice your displeasure that your niece (or cousin) isn't nude in front of
you.  But I could tell by their faces they were let down.

   "C'mon out and join us, Ara!" Kenzie shouted.

   "Shut up!" Ara said.  She was treading water more ferociously now,
trying to stir up some heat.  But it wasn't helping.  I could hear her
teeth chattering.

   Jim, Kevin, and the bridesmaids gave no signs of leaving.  Once, when
Jim got up to pour himself another drink, Ara neared the edge of the pool.
I thought she was going to go for it, but right as she grabbed onto the
ladder Jim turned back around to face her.

   "Noooo!" she murmured.

   "Just get it over with sweetie!" Michaela cried out.  "We won't bite!"

   Another 5 minutes or so passed and it was clear that no one was coming
to Ara's rescue.  She continued to shiver, and we all knew she wasn't going
to last much longer in the water.  She swam back over to the ladder and
took a deep breath.  She pulled herself partially out of the pool.

   "Whoah!" Jordan said, as we saw the top portion of Ara's chest - but
nothing else.

   "Ugggghhhh!" She groaned and dipped back underneath the surface.

   "BOOOOOOO!!!!!" The crowd yelled.

   Ara collected herself and again, made her way to exit.  She paused at
the ladder before taking a big exhale.  She closed her eyes and turned her
head, with a dimpled, nervous smile on her face.  She pulled herself
entirely out of the water and stepped onto the concrete to an eruption of
cheers.  She was dripping wet, hands on the ladder, and her cute rack and
bald little kitty were bared for our viewing pleasure!

   "YEAHHHHH!!!" Jordan and I exclaimed.

   "YIPPI KI-YAY!!" Jim joined in our cheers.  Ara had gotten out of the
water and cupped her pussy, but left her fun, mango shaped tits on show. 
"Ya got me that bachelor party after all, Kev!" Jim continued.

   Ara rolled her eyes and grabbed her robe.  She threw it on quickly, but
not before giving us all one last look at her front side.  "Hate you guys!"
She shouted at Maddy and Kenzie.  They were in a fit of laughter.  She sat
down with them around the fire, finally getting warmed up.

   "That it?!" Michaela let out a loud, obnoxious yawn.  Ara side eyed her.
Michaela and the rest of the bridesmaids got up and walked back inside.

   "Yeah, think it's time I hit the hay too.  Em's prolly wondering where I
am," Jim said.

   "Thanks for the show girls!" Kevin said and he walked away with Jim.

   "Man, you guys are a good time!" Jordan said once the crowd had
dispersed.  He looked extremely satisfied as he reclined his chair and
gazed up at the stars.  I voiced my agreement with him.  Briefly, just
briefly, that old jealous flicker emerged in Katie's eyes as she glanced
over at me.