Paul held Renee's hand as they followed Mindy and Becky, also holding hands, to his bedroom. He was about to ask what was going on when he stepped through the door and saw the 'new' bed. "When did this happen?"
"Do you remember your mother telling you to go see if either of your new sisters needed their backs washed because she needed my help with a 'project'?" Becky asked.
Paul nodded. "Yeah, I was wondering what she was up to that had to be done this late at night. Do you mean you two did this? I thought she just wanted to get you alone to give you the third degree about our date."
Becky giggled. "You know; she actually didn't get around to that. We were too busy flirting with each other!"
Mindy laughed. "She did? She must really like you, I could never get her to flirt with me!"
Paul froze as both Mindy and Becky took their t-shirts off, then pushed their panties to the floor. Becky took the smaller girl in her arms and tenderly kissed her on the lips. He didn't know how long he stood there staring at the beautiful sight, but he felt someone looking at him, and turned to look Renee in the eyes.
"Paul, I know you really don't know me yet, but I do know you. I've watched you, and learned all I could about you in school. I've had a bit of a crush on you since you started high school. I know you don't feel the same about me, but I'd like to see if we could love each other," Renee said, fear plain in her eyes.
"Sweetheart, I don't think you're going to have to worry about us loving each other. But you and your sisters will have to be patient with me while I try to figure this out. I want to make love to all of you, but only two of us can make love at a time," Paul said.
"Says who?" Mindy asked. She was out of breath from the kiss and was cuddled closely to her lover. "We're all shagged tonight, or I'd be willing to demonstrate, so if you can wait until tomorrow, I think I'd love to show all of you how much I'm falling for you."
Paul nodded but pulled Renee to him. She came willingly and seemed to mold herself to his body. "You're right, Peanut. I don't think I have the energy left to do as good a job as I want to. But if you two are going to sleep nude, it's going to be very hard to get to sleep."
"Well, I'm sure you'll be very hard before you go to sleep, but we will eventually sleep," Becky said. "I never wear clothes to bed, and I'd really like to feel the skin of those I love pressed against me. Trust me here; I've never slept so well as when Mindy and I would cuddle naked. So, if both of you would; please take your clothes off, and join your two girlfriends in bed?"
Renee bit her lower lip, and guided Paul's hands to the hem of the t-shirt she was wearing. She looked up, into his eyes with hope and love.
Yielding to her silent request, Paul lifted the shirt over her head, exposing her small breasts, and rock hard nipples to the light. He guided the shirt up and off her smaller body. She stood before him in nothing but panties, shivering like a thorough-bred.
Renee smiled at her love, and began helping him out of his clothes. Becky grinned and climbed into bed while Mindy helped her sister. Renee lifted Paul's shirt, but was too short to take it all the way off his arms, so he helped a little. Once the shirt was off his muscular chest, Renee gently put her arms around his ribs, softly kissed his breast and lay her head against his chest.
Mindy had knelt behind the pair, and reached around to unfasten her brother's jeans. She also untied his sneakers, allowing him to step out of them before she pulled his pants down. She left his briefs on, and once he'd stepped out of his jeans, she stood, kissed Renee, and both of them pulled his underwear down to reveal his rock hard cock. Renee giggled as Mindy leaned in and licked the precum off the tip.
Paul groaned and almost came. Becky, smiling widely on the bed, said, "Mindy, sweetheart, you're starting something we don't have the energy, or time to finish."
Mindy smiled back at her lover as she licked her lips. She turned back to Renee, and pulled her into a passionate kiss. She moaned as Renee grabbed her by the hair to pull her tighter to her.
Renee led her over to the bed, and pushed her down on her back without breaking the kiss. Reaching up, Renee pulled on Becky as she moved her body off to the side. Renee had put Mindy into the perfect position for Paul to make love to her.
Becky got out of bed, and took Paul's hand. He was staring like he'd never seen two girls loving each other before. (He hadn't) She pulled the stunned boy over to his little sister, and pulled him down so he was kneeling between Mindy's slender legs.
Becky leaned forward and took as much of his hard shaft in her mouth as she could, getting him wet with her spit. She sucked on the tip, and jacked the rest of his shaft once again causing him to groan. Becky began sliding her mouth up and down on his shaft pushing him as far in as she could. It didn't take much before he tried to warn her that he was about to shoot.
She backed off so just his head was in her mouth, and stroked him as he started to shake and pump cum into her mouth. She kept stroking him and swallowing. She loved the taste, though the texture would never be one of her favorite things in life.
He stayed hard, just like the stories said he would, though she didn't know if it was because of her efforts, or the sight of Mindy and Renee kissing and caressing each other. Becky spread Mindy's legs farther, and tapped Renee's hand for her to remove it from Mindy's dripping, hairless, little pussy.
"Paul?" Becky asked trying to get his attention. She had to squeeze his cock when she tried again. "Paul!" When he looked down at her, she smiled up at him, but got his attention on his sister's pussy. "You see this little flap of skin?" She pointed to a small piece of skin at the bottom of Mindy's slit. He nodded. "This is her hymen. This is what makes her physically a virgin. This is what gets torn when you make love to a woman. Try to remember that it hurts badly, and the girl would really like it if you didn't move until she tells you, after you tear it. Do you understand?"
Again he nodded, almost numbly, but she saw a twinkle in his eyes. He'd already known to wait, but she could tell he still appreciated her little lesson. She placed the head of his cock at the opening to Mindy's very tiny looking pussy, and backed away.
Renee had broken the kiss with Mindy, and had already backed away herself. Once Becky'd finished, and backed away, they held each other, cuddling and watching their lovers.
Paul looked down at his nude little sister, and suddenly remembered all the times he'd watched out for her, held her when she cried, and knew that Greg had been correct. They'd been in love since the day she was born. As one they looked up to their other two lovers. Paul knew that Becky had been part of that love as well, and now Renee had also joined them. Mindy reached out and took each of the other girls' hands.
As the two girls cuddled up to Mindy's sides, she nodded up to her ex-brother. "Now, Baby. Take me, then Becky and Renee. After tonight, nothing will ever come between the four of us."
As he looked at the three of them, he knew she was right. No matter how tired they were, they had to do this, and nothing would ever be the same again. Guided by instinct, he took Becky and Renee's other hands, then slowly pressed forward. At first nothing happened, but he could see the growing discomfort on Mindy's face, then suddenly, his cock popped past what was holding it, and slid half of his shaft into her very tight pussy. She grunted and a tear fell from one eye. Her eyes were shut tightly against the pain in her groin.
Paul felt both of the other girls also squeeze his hands like they too were in pain.
After waiting for her to tell him she was ready for more, Paul began making love to Mindy, but it was as though he were making love to all three of them. They all seemed to share the feeling.
When Paul finally entered Renee, he noticed she was just as tight as Mindy and Becky had been, but she hadn't had a hymen. He'd no more than gotten fully into her before she threw her arms around his neck, and held on for dear life. She had tears in her eyes as well, and Paul almost stopped to find out what was wrong, but she was urging him to continue. Very shortly she began cumming on her new lover. Paul didn't last very long either, and after he pumped his cum into little Renee, she clung to him tightly and cried. Very softly she chanted how much she loved them all.
Instead of questioning her about it, her three lovers covered themselves and her, and drifted off to sleep, wrapped up in their love.
Paul looked down at his three lovers. The girls were still sleeping, but they were so beautiful that he just stood there and watched them for a few moments. He heard a soft noise and knew Jen was probably in the kitchen making coffee and starting breakfast for the crowd in her home.
Paul pulled on his shorts, and headed for the kitchen for some coffee and to see if he could help her.
"Good morning, Mom. Is that coffee I smell?" Paul asked, grinning.
"Good morning, my handsome son. You're late! I expected you out here ten minutes ago with all the noise I was making!" Jen teased.
"Uh huh, you've been out here about five minutes. The only thing you've done is get the coffee on, and you were trying to be quiet. The first noise you made out here was your back cracking when you stretched. I would have been out here sooner, but I got distracted," Paul said and playfully stuck his tongue out at her.
Jen shook her head at him. "So that's how you always knew I was up. You know, you're kinda scary at times."
Paul smiled at his mother as he got two mugs down, and took up station next to the pot. He leaned against the counter to look at her.
"Since the cat is out of the bag so to speak, are you and your lovers going to keep separate houses?" Paul asked.
"We haven't had a chance to talk about it, but I can't see changing anything yet. I think we're going to have enough on our plates just keeping interest in the four of you to a minimum."
Paul smirked. "It'll help that all of us don't go to the same school, but if Mr. Bey's idea were to work, I can't have any interest in Renee at school." He got the coffee before sitting down at the table with her. "I'm sure everyone at Mindy and Becky's school knows about them. We might have to rethink the whole thing."
They sat in quiet companionship for a few moments. "I wonder what Captain Sparks is going to tell us when she gets here later," Paul said.
"I thought you knew, but had promised not to say anything?" Jen asked.
"I only know some of what's going on. I got the impression from the Captain that she was going to tell us more than I know."
Jen shrugged. "I don't know; I don't know what you do. I do hope she'll tell me where John is. I miss him so much it's almost unbearable, I think Tina feels the same."
"But what about Dad and Greg? Don't you love them?"
Jen frowned slightly. "It's not the same thing at all." She frowned deeper in thought. "I can't really explain it. It's like, I really, really like Lou and Greg, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't love them, but it's nothing like what I feel for John. I'm sorry I can't explain it very well."
Paul shrugged. "Okay, but I hope you understand, in my mind, Lou is my Dad. I love John, but he's Uncle John to me, I think it might be too late for him to take Lou's place as 'Dad'."
Jen nodded. "I know sweetheart, I never thought it would, and neither did Lou. I'm sure John knew it too, when he brought Lou and Greg to us."
Paul was feeling uncomfortable, so he changed the subject. "How about Pancakes and Sausage for breakfast? I'll cook!"
Jen grinned at him. "If you're cooking, it sounds fabulous!"
Since Pancakes were a favorite of the house, Paul knew there was plenty of mix, and syrup. He was unsure of the sausage, but found a pound of pre-made patties. He got two skillets and got the sausage going before mixing up the pancakes.
Jen got up to help him, but he smacked her on the butt and told her to sit down and quit bothering the cook. She squealed and kissed his cheek before doing what she was told.
The noise they were making, or maybe the smell of the cooking sausage, had begun to wake the rest of the household. As Paul's lovers came out, each one gave him a kiss before getting something to drink and sitting at the table. Mindy had been the first, and she immediately began setting the table for the rest. When Renee came out, she asked what she could do to help.
Mindy pointed. "Mugs are in that cupboard; could you get two and fill them with coffee please?" While Renee did as she was asked, Mindy finished setting the table.
"Here they are, sweetheart, where do you want them?" Renee asked.
Mindy pointed to two places at the newly expanded table. "These two spots, Love. Then we can sit down and drink them while Paul finishes the food."
Renee carefully sat the mugs down, then grabbed a surprised Mindy and kissed her fiercely. "Thank you," she said after letting the other girl go.
Just as Paul brought the first huge stack to the table, the doorbell rang. Jen motioned Paul to keep going, while she got up to answer the door.
Paul smiled after listening for a few minutes. "Mindy? Would you please set a place for Captain Sparks, and pour her a mug of coffee? I don't think the poor woman has gotten to sleep yet."