Chapter Nineteen
The second event that brought Seth further out of his funk was meeting a girl. Seth had been a virgin until college, and ever since then all the girls that he'd fucked had been seduced under the influence, as it were. So when Seth locked eyes with the stunning redhead across the cafeteria, he wasn't sure what to do. He had never seen her before, but there was an immediate attraction.
At first he wrote it off, because she was beautiful enough that he was sure that most guys, and probably most girls, would be immediately attracted to her as well. But throughout the meal, she kept meeting his eyes, so after he was done, he walked over to her table. She was sitting with some friends, but she seemed to be ignoring them as she watched him walk over.
Seth sat down at the table across from her and held out his hand. "Hi, I'm Seth."
One of the girl's friend said, "So?"
The girl took his hand, and they held them rather than shaking. "I'm Giselle," she said with a slight accent.
"Would you like to go out with me tonight?" Seth invited.
"OK," Giselle replied.
"Giselle!" her friend exclaimed.
"Meet you at the student center at eight?" Seth asked.
"That would be nice," Giselle responded.
"I'll see you then," Seth confirmed, getting up after very reluctantly releasing her hand. As he walked away, he heard her friends asking Giselle if she had lost her mind. He considered his mind as well. It was certainly not like him to just walk up to a girl, not knowing anything about her, and ask her out. He couldn't figure out why he did it, why he thought she'd accept, or why she accepted. But she did, and he was happy about that.
That night Seth met up with Giselle in the student center, where they grabbed a seat and didn't leave. They talked about their pasts and let the conversation roam where it wanted. After about three hours, Seth asked, "Is this weird?"
"Is what weird?" replied Giselle.
"Why did you say yes to going out with me?" Seth asked.
"I'm not sure," Giselle answered. "I just know that when I saw you, I wanted to get to know you better."
"Me too," Seth admitted. "I never believed in love at first sight, but I definitely felt an attraction at first sight! And I've never been this comfortable with anyone, other than my sister, especially not a total stranger!"
"Then I agree with you, it is weird," Giselle said. "I feel the same way."
Seth felt a little nibble of suspicion. "Look, I really like you," he said. "Can we take this a little slow? Maybe dinner and a movie tomorrow night?"
"Did you think that I would immediately take you into my bed?" Giselle asked playfully.
"I thought that might happen," Seth replied.
"Well, it might have," Giselle said with a smile. "You're certainly cute enough, and I like you a lot. But OK, tomorrow a dinner. And not student center food!"
Seth walked Giselle back to her dorm. The reason he hadn't seen her around was that she lived across campus, and had only been in his cafeteria that morning because she had been visiting with friends. Friends who didn't understand the instant attraction.
Seth kissed her at the door, a light kiss, though he had to fight not to make it something more. He left, practically skipping, and headed back to his dorm. Instead of proceeding to his room, he went to Sarah's. It was late, so he let himself in with his key. In the dim light from outside, he saw Betty sleeping in her little nest at the foot of the bed and Sarah sleeping under the covers.
Seth slipped off his shoes and slipped into bed next to Sarah, taking a moment to notice that she was naked.
"Sarah?" he whispered.
"Mmmm?" she asked sleepily.
"I need to talk to you," he said quietly.
Sarah opened her eyes and saw him lying with her, and she snuggled up onto him. "What's up?" she asked in a low tone, to avoid waking up Betty.
"Did you do anything in my head? Did you change something once when you visited?"
"No!" Sarah hissed. "You know I wouldn't do that!"
"The weirdest thing happened today," Seth told her. "I saw this girl from across the cafeteria, and I was drawn to her. I went over to her and asked her out tonight and she agreed! We met and talked for hours, and I'm telling you, it was like love at first sight for both of us!
"I thought about what we did to some people, and maybe it was like that for them, too. That's why I was wondering if you hadn't picked her out for me and given us each an attraction for each other."
"Maybe it really was just love at first sight?" Sarah speculated. "I need to meet this mystery woman, pronto!"
"I'm having dinner with her tomorrow, or rather, tonight," Seth said.
"I'm inviting myself and Betty along then," Sarah said.
"I don't think she'll mind; she's interested in meeting you, too, I'll let her know later," Seth yawned sleepily.
"Mmmmm, I like this," Sarah said, snuggling deeper into Seth. "Stay."
Soon they were both asleep. When Betty got up first in the morning, she was surprised to see the two of them in bed together. At first she smirked, thinking they had finally done it, but then she realized that Seth was still wearing his clothes. She woke them both up, and they got up without embarrassment. Seth went back to his room to change, and the girls got ready for their day.
Seth called Giselle's cell during the day to tell her where he was planning to take her to eat, and he confirmed that she was OK with her Sarah and Betty joining.
"Not even on a real date yet, and already you're having me meet the family?" she joked.
"My sister is closer to me than anyone in the world," Seth said. "When I told her how I felt about you, she insisted that she meet with you."
"And how do you feel about me?" Giselle asked soberly.
Seth mused the correct answer for a minute, then said, "Strongly."
"Interesting answer," Giselle said with a grin in her voice.
"The best you get after knowing you for only four hours," Seth replied.
"OK, we can have dinner with her," Giselle declared.
Seth had decided to do it right, and he made reservations at a reasonably upmarket place; he relished the excuse to see them dress up. When Seth went to get Sarah and Betty, he quite enjoyed the view. They were both wearing short black dresses, and both looked fabulous.
They went down to the parking lot and got in the car, the girls in the back seat. Seth drove over to pick up Giselle. She was waiting for him in the lobby, and he got a hug and kiss. She was wearing a green dress that set off the color of her hair. It dropped halfway between her hips and knees, and the top showed off more cleavage than Seth had realized she had.
They went outside and Seth held open the door for Giselle. As soon as she got in, she turned to the back seat to introduce herself to Sarah and Betty.
"I can tell that you're Sarah," Giselle said, holding out her hand. "I'm Giselle."
"Hi Giselle, nice to meet you," Sarah responded cordially. "I've heard quite a bit about you."
"When?" Giselle asked.
"Last night, after he left you, Seth came to see me," Sarah told her. "Don't worry, it was all good."
"That's a relief," Giselle sighed. "Seth speaks quite highly of you, too."
Seth had just slipped into the driver's side in time to hear that comment, as well as Sarah's reply of, "He'd better!"
Sarah then turned to indicate Betty and announced, "Giselle, this is my roommate Betty."
"Pleased to meet you," Betty said.
They chatted lightly until they got to the restaurant. Once there, Seth helped each of the girls out of the car, and they went in together.
"There are a lot of jealous guys in here," Sarah whispered.
"Why?" Seth asked.
"Well, you are here with three very hot ladies," Giselle said immodestly. "They're all wondering if you are doing all three of us."
Seth colored slightly, and Giselle smirked at him.
"He's so easy to embarrass," Sarah laughed.
"You're still not too old to put over my knee, young lady!" Seth growled with mock indignation.
"Young lady, hah!" Sarah exclaimed. "He's two minutes older than me and he thinks that makes him the boss of me!"
They sat down to a lovely dinner, and each of them got to know the other. Seth learned more about Giselle, and Sarah was brutal sharing details about a younger, geekier Seth. Betty stayed fairly quiet throughout the meal, only piping in when asked a question. They stayed at their table until the restaurant staff made them leave, so they could close.
Seth dropped off his sister and her slave, then drove to Giselle's dorm. "Walk with me," Giselle entreated, not wanting the night to end.
They started walking, holding each other's hands, in quiet speculation. Then Giselle observed, "You really love your sister, don't you?"
"More than anything," Seth said without hesitation. "Sometimes I feel like we're the same person. She's the most important person in the world to me."
"She feels the same way about you," Giselle noted. "I hope she liked me, because if she thinks that I'm not good enough for you, I think I'll be in real trouble."
"Don't worry, she liked you," Seth assured the pretty girl beside him.
"How can you be sure?" she asked.
"I know my sister," Seth said confidently.
"Well, you may have a conflict of interest here, but I'll have to trust you on that," Giselle said.
They continued along quietly for a few more minutes, then Giselle asked, "What's up between Sarah and Betty?"
"What do you mean?" Seth asked.
"Well, they're not quite romantic girlfriends, but they are definitely lovers," Giselle opined. "Sarah is definitely in control of that relationship, and you've slept with Betty, too."
"Why do you think that?" Seth asked, surprised and flustered.
"Because I'm observant," Giselle said.
"What exactly did you observe?" Seth asked.
"I saw the way that Betty looked at Sarah," Giselle began. "At first I thought that she had a huge crush on your sister, but the way that Sarah acted, the looks and touches that she gave Betty; it was clear that they were intimate. I don't know if there is some kind of hero worship, or something else, but Betty has it bad for your sister, and she'd do absolutely anything for her."
"And how does my sister feel about Betty?" Seth asked Giselle.
"She cares for Betty, but in a different way," Giselle continued. "I can't quite put my finger on it, but it's more proprietary than loving. That's why I think they're not just girlfriend/girlfriend."
"And Betty and me?" Seth asked.
"Again, the way that she looked at you, like she'd jump you in a second if she had the chance," Giselle said. "She's really quite transparent. Again, it might only be lust from afar, but you looked at her in a way that made it clear that you understood exactly what she was feeling. You wouldn't have known that unless you'd been intimate with her."
They walked silently again. "So how'd I do?" Giselle asked a short time later.
"Remarkably well," Seth acknowledged. "You are most perceptive."
More silence.
"Does it bother you?" Seth inquired.
"What?" Giselle said.
"Betty and me," Seth clarified.
"Not as much as your sister and you," Giselle replied.
Seth bristled at the thought of Giselle trying to separate him from his sister. Giselle caught the feeling and quickly said, "It's just that I'm not worried that Betty would steal your affections. I mean, I'm sure she'd make a great fuck buddy, but she'd never be your one and only. Your sister, on the other hand, I'd always be competing with her."
There was silence for a bit longer, and Seth began to mourn a beautiful relationship that had died before it could really begin.
Then Giselle continued, "It's a good thing that I'm not a jealous woman. If I were, I couldn't deal with you loving your sister more than you loved me. Luckily, I am firmly of the belief that there is not one love for each person, that a person is capable of boundless love, and the love for one does not reduce the love for another."
Hope soared in Seth. He stopped and turned to face Giselle, taking both of her hands in his. "Do you mean that? Do you really mean that?"
"Yes, Seth, I do," she said. "I'm not saying that I believe in open relationships and that if we go out, I don't care who you fuck. But I do believe that there can be more than one special person in one's life, and if I tried to keep you from yours, it would just make you resent me. I can love you, even knowing that you love others."
Seth just looked at her for a little bit, then slowly moved closer for a kiss. The kiss was sweet and long, but soon it went from sweet to passionate. Giselle broke off the kiss and said, "Let's go up!"
Seth looked around and realized that they had walked all the way back to his dorm. They went in and were all over each other in the elevator. Their pledge of going slowly went right to hell as Seth entered Giselle before their clothes even came off.
As soon as they were in the room, Seth pushed Giselle up against the back of the door. While he was kissing her deeply, running his hands all over her body, Giselle's hands were busy with the buttons of Seth's pants. In no time she had pushed his pants down to his ankles, his underwear soon following. Seth groaned as her hand squeezed his cock tightly. Seth reached under her skirt and found nothing put pussy.
"You hussy!" he hissed breathlessly.
"I know," she agreed. "Now fuck me!"
Seth grabbed Giselle by the ass and lifted her. Giselle wouldn't remove her hand from his dick until she had guided it into herself and her hand would no longer fit between them. Seth pushed Giselle against the door, trapping her between it and his body. She didn't seem to mind. Their first coupling was wild and animalistic; rutting rather than making love.
"I'm ... going ... to ... cum ... soon," Seth grunted, hammering into her.
"Do it! Do it! Do it!" she encouraged.
Seth did it, and managed to keep stroking despite his overly-sensitive dick until he brought Giselle off as well. Then he tiredly dropped to the floor, carefully pulling Giselle on top of him. He couldn't keep his cock in her while performing the maneuver, and Giselle groaned in disappointment as he popped out. The both lay panting for a few minutes.
Their initial lust satisfied, they slowly undressed each other and spent a significant amount of time getting to know each others' bodies. Seth spent a lot of time with his mouth all over Giselle's body. He felt such a strong pull to her that he wanted to get to know her inch by inch. He kissed down her front, around her neck and over her breasts. Giselle's breasts proved to be as round and firm as Sarah's, though her nipples were much lighter, just a tinge of blush.
As he continued his trip down, he licked her flat stomach, dipping his tongue in her naval and getting a pulling a little giggle from her. He kissed and licked both hips, sucking on them as she hissed in pleasure. Her pubic hair matched the color of the hair on her head, and her pussy lips were soft, wet and large. She had a long clit that she loved to have sucked, and she was multi-orgasmic, but Seth wouldn't find that out until later, because he only spent a small amount of time there before moving on. He kissed down her thighs and calves, nibbling at her ankles and sucking her toes.
When he reached the bottom, he had the lovely girl flip over, and he worked his way in reverse. The back of her knees were ticklish, and she squirmed under him as he played with that spot. He loved biting the crease where her ass met her thighs, and Giselle had no complaints about the teeth marks that he left. He licked up her back, and as he reached her neck she arched her hips. With only a little wriggling, Seth was able to plant his cock in her pussy. He stroked in and out, most of his weight crushing her oh so deliciously into the bed. After nibbling on her neck he got up on his knees, pulling her hips back with him so that he could get even deeper. He reached forward and wrapped her hair in his fist and pulled, making her arch her back even more and push her ass tightly into him. It was at this point that Seth learned that Giselle was multi-orgasmic, which she demonstrated over and over again until he collapsed onto her back, his cock oozing out of her, accompanied by their copious juices.
After this second go-around, Seth realized that he didn't have advance knowledge of Giselle's fantasies and sexual appetites. He also realized that Giselle was the first girl, other than Betty, that he fucked blindly, without preparation. Nevertheless, Seth performed admirably, and for the rest of the night, Giselle was quite vocal in encouraging him to do the things that she liked. It was very early in the morning when they finally collapsed in exhaustion.
The sun was already up when the door opened and Sarah walked in with a tray of food, Betty following along behind her carrying the drinks, wearing her short skirt and 'Slut' tee shirt and her collar with tag. Seth stirred and sat up, covering Giselle's exposed breasts and shaking her gently.
"We thought you might be hungry," Sarah chimed.
"What made you think that we'd be together here?" Seth asked.
"Please, I'm not stupid! I could see the way that you were looking at each other. Besides, you didn't come and see me, which I'm sure you would have had you not been otherwise occupied. That, plus the fact that you don't have a roommate, and I thought it was a pretty safe bet that I'd find you here."
"Your sister is quite perceptive as well," Giselle chuckled. She sat up, and the blanket fell to her waist.
Sarah took a look and unashamedly said, "Nice! You did good, bro." Seth just blushed.
Sarah and Betty had brought enough food for the four of them, and they sat down on the bed, unconcerned about the others' nudity or the smell of sex in the air. Giselle, likewise, was unbothered, sitting and gabbing while she ate.
Seth, on the other hand, was beside himself. His sister was sitting on the bed, chatting with his naked girlfriend, and he was naked as well, with a piss hard-on tenting the blanket.
"Um, I need to go to the bathroom," Seth muttered.
"You go, we'll entertain Giselle," Sarah said dismissively, and Betty smirked.
Seth got up with as much dignity as he could, considering his cock was sticking out at a right angle to his body. He grabbed a robe, but before he could put it on Giselle said to the other girls, "Nice and big, and he can use it too, right?"
"Oh yeah," Betty said fondly, and Sarah snorted in laughter as Betty turned red at her tacit admission.
Seth escaped the room, and Giselle said, "Don't worry, I'm not jealous of you." Then she regarded Sarah and added, "Much."
"You don't mind our barging in?" asked Sarah.
"Not at all," Giselle responded. "I told Seth last night. I know that he loves you, and that will never change, but I think that he might be able to love me as well."
"I think he already does," Sarah said.
Giselle just smiled.
"You know, I'm not sleeping with Seth," Sarah informed Giselle matter of factly.
"It doesn't bother me one way or the other," Giselle replied. "I can tell that the two of you are extremely close."
"We are, but I've never even played with his cock," Sarah went on. "Actually, that's not true. When we were seven we played doctor. It was much smaller then."
"I'll bet," Giselle tittered.
"As you heard, Seth has had Betty," Sarah continued. "She enjoyed it quite a bit."
Betty blushed again.
"If last night was typical, then that doesn't surprise me," Giselle said.
Seth returned and sat on the bed, his robe firmly tied around his waist. He ate the food that the girls had brought, then said to Giselle, "Damn, I forgot I left the car over at your dorm."
"Ah well, I guess I'll have to do the walk of shame in my crumpled evening dress," Giselle lamented.
"Nonsense," Sarah contradicted. "Come up and get some clothes from me while Seth goes and gets the car, and then he can drive you back."
"I'll take you up on the offer of clothes, but I'll walk back with Seth," Giselle insisted.
Seth slipped on some clothes, his back modestly turned towards the girls, and then they all trooped upstairs. Since their builds were relatively the same, a tee shirt and a skirt from Sarah fit Giselle fine. Sarah was being intentionally clever when she gave Giselle the thin tee shirt, knowing that she didn't have a bra with her. Giselle didn't seem to mind.
Seth noticed Giselle looking carefully around Sarah's room. Knowing how perceptive she was, she might very well pick up on the furniture setup, correlate it with the collar and tag, and come away with the correct answer.
"It really was lovely meeting both of you," Giselle exclaimed, hugging each of the girls in turn.
"I think we are going to become good friends," Sarah told her.
Seth walked Giselle out and towards her dorm.
"You know that I figured it out," she said.
"Figured what out," Seth replied, playing dumb.
Giselle gave him a don't-be-stupid look and said, "Your sister's relationship with Betty."
"And that is?" Seth asked.
"Mistress, Domme, Owner," she declared. "I'm not exactly sure which, but one applies."
Seth smiled. "She wasn't exactly trying to hide it. I think that means that she feels you'll be around us a lot, and it's not worth trying to keep secrets from you."
"I interpreted it that way as well, and I'm very happy for it," Giselle said.
When they got to his car, he kissed Giselle good bye and drove back to his dorm. He immediately went to Sarah's room, where the two girls were waiting for him.
"Well?" he asked.
"You know the answer," Sarah said.
"Why were you flaunting your relationship?" he asked.
"She was going to figure it out soon anyway, so I figured I might as well give it a head start. Besides, she's still new enough to embarrass Betty, so it was an added benefit. When is she moving in?"
"We said we'd take it slow," Seth confided. "Of course, I hadn't intended to sleep with her this fast either."
"Ha!" Sarah chortled. "She'll be moved in within a week."
"Betty, go to the common room and wait there until I come and get you," Sarah instructed.
"OK," Betty replied without complaint.
When she had left, Sarah asked, "Have you visited with her?"
"No, and I'm not planning to," Seth said firmly.
"I didn't think so," Sarah said. "That's why I did last night."
"You what!" Seth yelled. "You knew very well that I wouldn't have wanted that."
"You're right, I did know that you wouldn't approve," Sarah responded without apology. "But that's why I did it. Because you would be too blinded by love to even try."
"I don't want to know what you found," Seth insisted.
"I know that too, but I'm still going to tell you some of it," Sarah said. "You need to know.
"First of all, as you probably already figured out, I approve of her. I didn't do a deep dive, but everything I saw I liked. She's an open and honest girl. Second, I was there when she was telling you that she could still love you if you loved me."
"Did you influence her in any way?" Seth accused.
"You know that I didn't," Sarah said calmly, accepting the state of mind that her brother was in. "Her thinking was not impaired at all, so I couldn't have if I wanted to, which I did not. But Seth, she was thinking that we were sleeping together, and that Betty joins us, and she is OK with that. In fact, she was thinking that she might like joining us."
"What?" Seth said, sitting down hard.
"She knows we love each other, and not knowing our secret, it would be easy to think that we were having sex. Especially after I barged in on you this morning and didn't flinch at your nudity. I told her that we weren't sleeping together, but she was honest when she said that she wouldn't interfere with your love for me, even when she thought it was more physical than it is."
Sarah paused for a moment, then said, "And to be honest, I wouldn't kick her out of my bed either."
"Argh! I'm surrounded by devil women!" Seth said.
"And loving it!" Sarah snorted.
Sarah was right about the speed with which her brother and his new girlfriend were moving, of course. Two days later Giselle moved into Seth's room. She made it quite clear that Sarah and Betty were welcome in the room absolutely any time at all. She and Seth went up to Sarah's room quite a bit, too, and Betty was not allowed to dress for her, which Giselle did not mind at all.