Sammi’s Prom Night

I will never forget my prom or what happened after it. David escorted me, of course, and it was just a magical evening. He’s a great dancer and all my female friends were jealous that I have such a gorgeous man.

After prom David took me to Nathan’s house. We were still dressed up and Nathan gave us catcalls when we walked in. I was a little uncomfortable at first seeing Nathan because I hadn’t seen him since David told me about them. Maybe I was more jealous then uncomfortable. Knowing that Nathan had been with my man (even though it was before he was mine) made me a little jealous. While David got us some drinks Nathan and I sat on the couch.

“Have a good time tonight Sammi?” He asked me, looking at my cleavage. My dress was a short black number, nothing fancy really. Just straight, short (stops mid-thigh) and the top was low cut, and my cleavage was showing.

“If you’re going to ask me a question,” I said, “ask me and not my breasts.” Nathan looked at me in surprise. I just grinned. I hated it when guys did that, asked my breasts the questions.

“Sorry. So you had a good time? David nail you in the bathroom or anything?” He asked, with a smile on his face.

“We had a great time and no he didn’t nail me in the bathroom,” I giggled. I leaned forward closer to his face. “He hasn’t nailed me yet, but he did finger me on the way here,” I whispered. His jaw dropped and I laughed, leaning back again. I loved to shock Nathan.

“Hey what’s going on?” David asked. I looked up and noticed he was standing in front of me. I took my drink from him and smiled.

“Nothing,” I said. He smiled back and sat down in between Nathan and I.

“Sammi was just telling me about the good time she had with you on the way over here,” Nathan grinned. I almost choked on my drink and David laughed. He looked over at me.

“She did, did she?” My eyes were wide. David had really fingered me on the way to Nathan’s, and I knew I should have kept my mouth shut but I had to get Nathan’s goat somehow. I’m glad I did.

“Yea man, said you did something with this hand,” Nathan said, grabbing David’s right hand and bringing it to his face. Nathan sniffed and smiled, then licked David’s index finger. “Nice sample,” he smiled at me. “You’re right David she does have a nice taste.”

“David!” I giggled. “You said that?”

“That’s not all he said,” Nathan smiled. David smiled at me and I had to smile back. I wanted to know what all he said.

“Tell me,” I said.

“Sammi,” David laughed. “It’s just guy talk.”

“Tell me, Nathan,” I smiled. “I have a right to know.”

“David, she does have a right,” Nathan smiled. “He said that your pussy tastes like honey, and that when he eats you after you get out of the shower it’s raspberry flavored. He said that you have great tits, that he loves to just suck your nipples and feel your hands in his hair when he does. He said that you have a great ass, and one day he’d like to--”

“Nathan that’s enough!” David exclaimed, looking at me. He looked a little upset, and I felt a little bad. But I was glad to know that he really did enjoy me.

“David,” I whispered as I leaned over to him. “It’s ok, really.”

“It’s just between guys.”

“I want to be between you guys,” I whispered, giving him a wicked smile. It was a major fantasy of mine, to be in a threesome with him and Nathan, and I guess I saw the opportunity for it. David looked shocked.

“What?”

“Remember we talked about fantasies? We talked about this, I want to do this and who better than Nathan? I want to see you two together, and I want to be with both of you at the same time.”

“Holy shit,” he whispered. “Let me ask Nathan, ok?” I nodded, and he leaned over to Nathan. They whispered amongst themselves for a few minutes, then they both looked at me. “Ground rules,” David said. “One, I want to make it clear to both of you where I stand. Nathan, you’re my best friend and I love you but I’m in love with Sammi completely and nothing will change that. Got it?”

“Yea,” Nathan said. “I know that.” I just nodded. I couldn’t believe it was going to happen.

“Two, Sammi we ask you to do something and you say no then we respect that. If you feel uncomfortable, we respect that. Ok?”

“Yea baby,” I smiled. I got up off the couch, put my drink on the end table and stood in front of them. David was in his tux; well his jacket was off but he still had the shirt, tie and pants on. He kicked his shoes off as soon as he got in the apartment. Nathan was just wearing a black t-shirt and tight blue jeans. He looked relaxed, looking up at me with his bedroom eyes. I got on them, they were side by side and I got on David’s left leg and Nathan’s right one. I sat so their legs were between mine and I looked from one to the other. I leaned to David and kissed him, then felt a hand on my right thigh. I ended the kiss and looked at Nathan, then kissed him.

I had never kissed any man but David and it was different. Nathan kissed great, different style then David and I liked it. We kissed for a few more minutes then we parted. I looked at David and he smiled at me, then he leaned over and kissed Nathan. It was so beautiful. I was in heaven just watching them, it was nothing compared to my fantasies about it. I watched them, placing my hands on their legs and relaxing. When they parted they both looked at me, and we were all panting.

“I’m so hot,” Nathan panted. “Take your dress off babe.”

“Yea, Sammi,” David said. “I paid $150 for that and I don’t want to get anything on it.” I laughed and got off them and slowly unzipped my dress. I picked the dress up and draped it over the nearest chair, then returned to stand in front of them. I had no panties or bra on under it and had just let it fall. David whistled at me.

“God. Damn,” Nathan whispered. All I had on was a pair of black thigh highs and black high heels. “Get back here!” He said, patting his leg. I got back on their legs and their hands were all over me. Nathan was busy with my breasts while David caressed my back and bottom. I was watching Nathan’s face and saw he noticed my scar. He looked up at me.

“Don’t ask,” I whispered.

“Ok,” he nodded. “You know, you can get a tattoo to cover that up. I know a guy who’ll do it cheap, he owes me.”

“I’ll think about it.” He nodded, then lowered his head and did the same thing David did the first time he saw my scar; he gently kissed and licked at it like he could make it go away. I moaned softly, running my hands through his hair bringing him closer to my nipple. He started to gently suck on my nipple and I looked over to David. We both smiled, and he kissed me. I wrapped an arm around his neck and we parted our faces a little. He gave me another smile, then moved so he could kiss my other breast. In a few minutes both of them were sucking my nipples and licking my areoles and I was hotter than anything. I had never had the feelings I was having and it was sending me into overload. I started moaning louder and moving my hips slightly. I had my hands in their hair and they were just going to town on me. After a moment I felt a hand on my pussy, and I saw it was David’s. He pressed his palm against me and I started rubbing myself against him. My moaning got louder and their sucking got harder and then I felt more pressure between my legs and I realized that Nathan had his hand under David’s and they were pushing up and I came so hard on David’s palm.

“Sam oh baby,” David whispered. I was trembling, moaning, my eyes closed tight and my hands gripping their hair. They both gave me a few minutes to calm down, then I let go of both of them. I watched as Nathan took David’s hand and licked my juices off him.

“That good Nathan?” I smiled. He smiled back and nodded. I got off their legs and stood up, then stretched. They both watched me. “Well, what now?” I asked. Nathan stood up.

“Bedroom. I think we’ll need the room,” he grinned. David got up too and he and I followed Nathan into the bedroom. I sat on the bed and they stood in front of me. Nathan pulled his shirt off and I smiled. Nice chest. Almost no hair and great muscles. He got on his knees in front of me and took my heels off. I looked at David and he had his shirt off, his pants unbuttoned. He smiled at me, then sat down beside me. Nathan spread my thighs, and David lifted one of my legs onto his. “Oh Sammi I can smell your pussy,” Nathan whispered. He leaned his head down and licked up me. I moaned, trying not to fall on my back. I wanted to watch Nathan eat me, I wanted to watch David watch. I looked at David and he was staring, then he looked up at me.

“Wow,” he whispered. I smiled, moaning, and pulled him to me. “Samantha, I love you,” he moaned into my ear as I held to him. “Watching him eat you is awesome.” He turned his head and we were both watching Nathan. He had my thighs spread wide and sticking his tongue deep inside me. I was so turned on that it took me no time to cum on his tongue. He slurped me up and the sound seemed to echo through the room.

“Oh shit,” I moaned. I’d never cum that fast before. I pushed Nathan away and then collapsed on my back. My poor clit, it couldn’t take any more touching for awhile and I knew it. Just the cool air on it was making me shudder. I closed my legs as Nathan climbed on the bed.

“Honey,” Nathan grinned. “You do taste like it, thick and sweet.” David laughed and pulled me into his arms. I collapsed against him. “Did I break her?”

“No,” David laughed. “She gets like this when I eat her sometimes. She’s too sensitive to be touched for awhile.” I looked at Nathan, then David. “Yea sweetie?”

“Kiss him,” I whispered. David nodded, then grabbed Nathan’s shoulder and pulled him to him. They kissed, and I watched. I quietly pulled away and watched as they got into the kiss. I thought I would get jealous, but I didn’t. They wrapped their arms around each other and they laid down. I got closer, moving so I was sitting beside them. David ended the kiss and looked at me.

“Tell me,” he whispered.

“It’s ok, David,” I said. “It’s ok.” He nodded, then they started kissing again. Nathan was on top of David, and they looked so sexy together. I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to describe how beautiful it was watching them. Nathan got off David and then off the bed, and he undressed the rest of the way. His dick wasn’t as big as David’s but it was nice. It was about 6 inches and very thick. I liked it. “Very nice, Nathan,” I smiled.

“Thank you Sammi, dear,” he smiled back. He looked at David. “Your turn.” David nodded and got off the bed, kissing Nathan before Nathan took his place on the bed. I got up against Nathan and we both watched David as he took his dress pants and boxers off. My Mr. Big was huge! He was hard and precum was oozing off the tip. He had enjoyed watching Nathan go down on me I could tell. He got on the bed, and he and Nathan kissed again.

“Sammi,” David said, “will it gross you out if Nathan and I do more than kiss?”

“No,” I smiled.

“Ok.” He and Nathan looked at each other, then they moved around. David sat beside me and Nathan got on his stomach between his legs. I put my arms around David and rested my head on his shoulder and watched as Nathan started to lick his bellybutton. He was breathing hard as Nathan licked his way down to his pubic hair. When Nathan bypassed his pubic hair I knew that that was something that David had told only me, and I smiled. Nathan gently took David’s cock in his hand and started to lick up his shaft. David moaned softly, putting his hand on Nathan’s shoulder. I watched as Nathan slowly took the head of his cock into his mouth and David moaned louder. I don’t know what exactly Nathan did to my man’s cock while it was in his mouth, but David went wild. He grabbed Nathan’s head and started a constant moan, and he grabbed my head too and pulled it to his face. We kissed long and hard, listening to Nathan slurp on his cock.

“Are you going to cum soon?” I asked. He made a painful groan and I looked and saw that Nathan had stopped sucking him.

“Samantha,” Nathan said softly, “do you mind if David fucks me? It’s been so long since I’ve had a real man.” I pulled Nathan up so his face was close to mine. I kissed him, taking him by surprise. I could taste David on him, it was erotic. “I take that as a yes?” I nodded. “Oh thank you, thank you Sammi!” He kissed me again, then when he let go of me David kissed me again.

“Get me a condom, Nathan,” David told him. Nathan nodded and got off the bed. I looked at David. “You sure you’re comfortable with this?”

“Yea, yea,” I grinned. “I’ve seen pictures on the net, I know what to expect, and you know that I think it’s sexy.”

“I know, but this real life, not pictures.” Just then Nathan got back on the bed, opening a condom package. David and I had never used one and I watched as Nathan put it on David.

“Ready, David? I know I am.” I giggled at what Nathan said, I had said that to David a few times. David nodded, and Nathan turned around, getting on his hands and knees. Nathan had a great ass, let me tell you. It wasn’t really hairy, and it was in shape. I had never really noticed before. I watched as David got into the nightstand and got out a little tube.

“It’s always there,” David said. I guess I gave him a look. He applied what was in the tube liberally to Nathan, then to his condom covered cock. I was getting a little nervous, I had never seen this, never even done it. David scooted forward and pressed the head of his cock against Nathan’s tiny opening. “Wanna try for it all this time?” David asked,

“There’s no way,” Nathan laughed. “You know how much I can take.”

“Got it.” Then David pressed against Nathan and I saw the head of his cock pop in. “Who’ve you been with?”

“My dildo,” Nathan breathed.

“I can tell, you’re not as tight.” David pressed further, and I watched his shaft slide in. He worked himself in slowly, until half of his cock was in. All the while Nathan was groaning and moaning, gripping the sheets under him. “How’s that?”

“Oh god! No more.” He was panting, and shaking a little. I watched as David withdrew all the way, then he pushed back in again. “Oh David,” he moaned. David was groaning as he re-entered Nathan. I watched as he slowly stroked inside Nathan a few times, then I crawled to Nathan. I sat facing him and he looked at me, and you could tell he was having an awesome time. “Sammi,” he whispered. I leaned forward and kissed him. He kissed me hard, almost sucking my tongue out my mouth.

“Hey Samantha,” David panted. I looked up at him. “Give him a hand.” It took a minute to realize what he meant, then I grinned. I crawled around Nathan and sat so I was beside him. I then gently grasped his cock that was very rigid and I began to slowly pump him.

“Oh god!” Nathan cried out. David had taught me the fine art of handjobs and I could tell Nathan liked it. Plus combined with the feeling of David inside him, he was in heaven. “Cum, gonna cum,” he panted. I continued pumping him and David continued to slowly fuck him. It was amazing. Here I am, a virgin until four months ago now watching my boyfriend plunge his dick in his best friend’s ass while I jerked him off. My life had changed big time.

“He’s cumming,” David whispered. I nodded, I knew Nathan was, I could feel it. “He’s squeezing me hard.” So that’s how he knew, I thought to myself. I had no idea. I didn’t know a lot about what I was seeing. I knew about the cumming though, Nathan had got a lot on my hand and the rest on his bedspread. David slowly drew himself out of Nathan and he collapsed onto his butt while Nathan collapsed onto his stomach. I just sat there, my hand covered in Nathan’s cum and wondering if this is what I really wanted. What clinched it was when David leaned toward me. “I love you for letting me do this. I want you to know that, I really love you for this. And I’ll do the same for you Sammi, if you want.”

“Ok,” I nodded. I grinned, then slowly licked my hand as he watched.

“I’m going to get cleaned up, ok?” He asked. I nodded, then kissed him.

“I love you too, David,” I whispered. He grinned and got off the bed, then left the room. I crawled back to Nathan, who was still on his stomach and panting. “Nathan?” I asked. He turned his head and looked at me, a dreamy look in his eyes. “You ok?”

“Yea,” he smiled. “I’m good. I need to get up though and get cleaned up, I’m a mess.” I nodded and moved, then got off the bed. I looked around his room while he got up and started pulling the bedspread off. He had a dresser, and on it were some pictures that shocked me. One was of he and David, taken before I knew them, before Nathan had brown hair. He was blonde, and they had their arms around each other. Another picture was of Nathan and a girl I didn’t know, she was pretty and they were hugging. The next picture was of me and David, taken at a party Nathan threw about a month before. David and I were kissing passionately, we were in the kitchen. I didn’t know that pic was taken of us, I thought we were alone. The last picture was of Nathan and Margie, the woman I worked with. They were wrapped in each other’s arms. I got shivers. I turned and Nathan was behind me.

“Explain to me why you have a picture of you and my married friend, and why you have a picture that I know I didn’t give permission for you to take,” I said in a shaky voice. “Now Nathan tell me now!”

“Calm down!” He exclaimed. “Look, don’t get mad ok? I’ve always thought you and David were beautiful together, and I saw you two in the kitchen and I took that pic. I was going to give it to you the next time I saw you and that would be tonight but we got busy,” he chuckled. “And Margie is just a friend. That was taken a year ago, before she got married. She didn’t want you to think bad of her, that she saw me before she got married so she asked me not to tell you. She asked me to just act like she and I were nothing more than friends.”

“Oh Nathan.” I could tell by the look in his eyes and his voice that she had hurt him. “I’m sorry, I didn’t know. It’s ok.”

“Yea. Well, I’m gonna go clean up. That pic of you and David is yours, I thought you would think it was as beautiful as I did.” He started to the door.

“I think it is beautiful, Nathan, thank you,” I smiled at him. I picked up the pic and took it to the bed with me. David walked in a minute later and sat with me.

“Who took that? And when?” He asked, taking the pic from me.

“Nathan, last month. He thought it was beautiful, wanted us to have it. Did you know he dated Margie?” I asked.

“He dated a Margie, yea she broke his heart. That’s why he goes through women like he does now. He doesn’t trust anymore.” He looked at me. “You know her?”

“She works with me, at the cd store. I didn’t know until I saw the pic of them.”

“Oh. I’ve never seen his Margie, I didn’t know. Anyway, he cleaning up?”

“Yea.”

“He’ll take a few minutes. I cleaned up for you,” he grinned. It was that grin he gives me when he wants a blowjob.

“Oh did you now?” I smiled, taking the picture back from him. I put it on the night table then pulled him into my arms. “You cleaned really well, huh?”

“Yes, plus I had a condom on. Will you play with me a little, ‘til Nathan gets back here?” I nodded, giggling a little.

“Are you going to let Nathan fuck you?” I whispered.

“If it’s ok with you.” I nodded, then got off the bed and got on my knees in front of him. He wasn’t as hard as he had been, I guess because he had washed off, but that didn’t phase me. I just stuffed him into my mouth, thankful that he smelled and tasted like soap. I took in as much as I could and he put his hands on my head, gently guiding me. “That’s so good Samantha, so good,” he moaned. “I’m gonna cum, baby, soon.”

“Mmmm-mmmm,” I moaned. I tried to say ‘That’s ok’ but well, I couldn’t. He knew that I didn’t mind, and he started moaning louder.

“Hey, David,” Nathan said from behind me, “cum on her tits and we can lick it off.” I just kept sucking.

“I’ve never done that to her before,” David groaned.

“First time for everything,” Nathan laughed. “That’s what this night is apparently.”

“Sammi, stop baby.” I released him and looked up at him. He stood up and started jerking off, and I held my tits up for him. I loved watching him, loved the way he looks when he’s about to cum and he made his look. Then he came, all over my breasts, and a lot. “Oh fuck, Sammi,” he moaned. Then Nathan was on the floor in front of me and started licking it up.

“Wow,” I whispered. This was interesting, I never knew David was into this. I mean, he’s eaten me a few times after he’s cum in me but this was different. It wasn’t mixed with me. I watched as he joined Nathan on the floor and started licking with him. “Wow,” I moaned. Two men, licking at my breasts again. I have to admit, it was dirty and I loved it. They finished a few minutes later, and I was panting heavy.

“How ya feeling?” David asked.

“Wow!” I laughed. “That was like, so erotic. You two are so erotic!”

“Thanks!” David laughed. Nathan grinned at me.

“I know what you want,” I smiled. “Sit on the bed.” Nathan got on the bed and I motioned for David to get in between his legs. “I want to see you do this,” I said softly. David nodded and got in front of Nathan, getting on his knees. He took Nathan’s flaccid cock in his hand then his mouth. I watched in complete fascination as my boyfriend went down on him. Wow! He was a pro at it too, he had Nathan hard in no time. After a few more minutes I spoke again. “Stop.” David did, and he looked at me. “I don’t want him cumming yet.”

“You’re gonna let me?” Nathan asked. I nodded. “I’ll get a condom.” He got off the bed and went to his dresser, getting another condom out. “I’m gonna fuck David,” he grinned as he walked back to us. “On your back on the bed!” David laughed and got on the bed, then on his back. I got on the bed too, getting on David’s left side. Nathan got on the bed in between David’s legs and put his condom on. “I know you can take all of me,” Nathan smiled.

“Yes,” David smiled back. “Just be easy, haven’t done this in over a year.”

“What, Sammi doesn’t even finger you?”

“Never asked,” David replied. I’d never thought about really, not even after he told me was bi. Something to think about now. I watched as Nathan pressed himself against David and the head popped in. “Mmph,” he moaned.

“What aren’t you using any of that stuff on him?” I asked Nathan.

“He likes it like this.” Ok, I thought. I watched as Nathan worked himself in David, and then he was all the way in.

“Wow!” I said softly. David was moaning, his cock hard again and dripping precum. Nathan was moaning about how tight he was, and said he didn’t know how long he’d last. That was ok with me, I just wanted to see David take it. I knew if he could take it, then I could. And I wanted to. I leaned down and started sucking on David’s cock.

“Oh fuck!” David cried out. “Oh my… oh fuck!” I was positioned so I could watch Nathan fuck him and boy did I watch. I got so wet, it was awesome. My baby was getting the best of both worlds at one time and I made it possible. “Samantha Ann,” he moaned. “Nathan, god.” I sucked as I watched Nathan start to really fuck David. It was beautiful. Nothing can describe it. I stopped sucking David, and watched as Nathan came. He pounded David, making him squeal, then he pulled out. David was still hard, still dripping precum.

“Oh David,” Nathan moaned. “Wonderful as ever.”

“No doubt,” David whispered. “I didn’t get to cum though, damnit.”

“Nathan, can you get hard again?” I asked. David looked up at me in shock. “I told you, I want to be in between you guys.”

“How?” He asked.

“Well,” I said as I leaned down, “I want you in the back and Nathan in the front. I’ve shared you with him, now you can share me with him.”

“Hot damn. A dream come true, I’ve never done that with a girl.” He gave me a smile then frowned. “It’ll hurt. It did my first time.”

“You never told me it hurt,” Nathan said. David looked at him.

“Like you didn’t hurt?”

“True.”

“But I want to do this,” I told David. “Please. I want to be your first girl for this, I want to be the first person to take you all the way inside me.”

“Sammi, that is gonna hurt, I’ve tried it,” Nathan said softly.

“Please,” I begged. “At least try! Use that stuff you used on Nathan earlier. Anything, I really want to try it. You look like it feels like the greatest thing I want to experience it too.” There I was, naked and on my hands and knees, begging my boyfriend to do to me what he had done to him.

“You’re totally sure?” David asked. “Cause, I’ll do it.”

“I’m sure,” I whispered. It was going to happen. I was going to have the most dirtiest thing done to me. And someone was going to watch.

“Get Nathan hard, as soon as he gets cleaned up,” David whispered. I nodded. I think David knew I would do anything at this point. Nathan got off the bed and left the room, leaving me and David. I decided to get bold. I got between David’s legs and looked at him. “What are you doing?” I took my right hand and gently touched him where Nathan had been. “Easy,” he whispered. I nodded, then gently pushed my index and middle finger inside him. The lubricant from the condom was still there, and my fingers went in easily. “Oooh,” he groaned. I started to gently finger him, and he was in heaven and I really liked it. I had never felt anything like it, it was so different than a pussy. It was tight, but not as wet, and it was really hot.

“You’re not wasting anytime learning new tricks,” Nathan said as he got on the bed. “That’s sexy, I’ve never seen that before like this.” He got right beside me and rested his head on my shoulder. “He’ll do this to you before he fucks you,” Nathan whispered. “Has he fingered your ass before?”

“Yea,” I whispered back. “I like it, too.”

“Stop Sammi, please,” David whimpered. I stopped fingering him and looked at him. He was panting, his cock hard as a rock. “Oh god.” I giggled at him, leaning back against Nathan. David looked at both of us. “Give me a minute.” I nodded, then turned to face Nathan. We kissed, Nathan’s hand going to my breast. He gently pinched my nipple, and I liked it.

“Mmmm,” I moaned. I turned and pushed myself against Nathan. I felt weird kissing and getting this close to him, but I was so turned on. Nathan fell on his back and I went with him, lying on top of him. We were still kissing, and now both his hands were on my breasts pinching my nipples. I spread my legs and straddled him, feeling his limp cock against me. I was wet, and I knew I soaked him. That’s what got him hard I think. A few minutes of us kissing and him playing with my breasts he started to get hard again. “Oh Nathan I think that you like me,” I teased.

“You have one little hot body baby,” he grinned. “David, do I use a condom on her?”

“Yes,” David said really fast. I felt him move and get off the bed, and Nathan and I started kissing again. A second later David was back, sitting beside us. “Here,” he said. I ended the kiss then got off Nathan. I watched as David put the condom on Nathan, it was really sexy.

“Are you going to wear a condom with me?” I asked David. He leaned close to me, so our faces were almost touching.

“No. I want to feel your hot little ass wrapped around every inch of me.” He licked my bottom lip, then grinned. “I want to cum in your ass. I want you to be the first to feel me cum in their ass.”

“Oh god,” I moaned. I grabbed him by the shoulders and kissed him hard. I love it when he talks dirty like that to me. David ended the kiss, then smiled.

“Get on him baby, sit on his cock.” I just nodded, totally dripping wet and ready. I straddled Nathan, David holding his cock and guiding him in as I sat on him. Nathan and I both moaned as he went in to the hilt. “Sexy. Sit right there.”

“Ok,” I nodded. Nathan and I looked at each other. I was in a mild state of shock. I had another man inside me, and I liked it. It felt great. Not as good as David, but it still felt great. Then I felt David behind me, his hands on my back.

“Lie on top of him,” he said. I did, pressing my breasts to Nathan’s chest. We smiled at each other, then he kissed my forehead. I felt David press his finger against me, and he started a gentle fingering.

“Oooh,” I moaned, grabbing Nathan’s shoulders.

“Baby, you’re squeezing my dick hard,” Nathan moaned. Then David inserted another finger. I groaned loudly and started rocking my hips in time with him. “Oh Sammi!” Nathan groaned. I couldn’t say anything, just moaned loudly. “So tight,” he whispered. After a few minutes, David stopped fingering me and I felt him move around on the bed. After a minute I felt something wet and cool against me, then David pushed it inside with his fingers.

“What is that?” I asked.

“It’s lubrication. It’s ok,” David said. “I’m gonna put some on my cock too to make it as painless as possible.”

“Sweet of you,” I moaned. The feeling of Nathan in me and David’s fingers in me was really getting to me. Then David stopped, pulling his fingers from me. After a few moments I felt what I knew was the head of David’s cock against my tiny opening. I stopped moving on Nathan and sat still, and David slowly entered me. He slowly worked the head in then stopped. I was breathing hard, holding onto Nathan’s shoulders for dear life.

“Sammi, ok baby?” David asked.

“Yea,” I whispered. I looked at Nathan, and he grinned at me. “More.” David started to slowly push, and I felt more go in.

“I’m not stopping til it’s all in,” David whispered. He didn’t either, and I was crying out against Nathan’s chest. It didn’t hurt too badly, the lubrication stuff David used made it really smooth and the only thing that really hurt was my ass stretching out to make room for him. It felt so awesome; this long, hard, thick cock in my tiny little ass. I didn’t honestly think I could take it but I did. “I am going to cum really soon,” David moaned. “Nathan she is so tight, and she’s squeezing me hard.”

“Just wait,” Nathan grinned. He pushed me up a little so my breasts weren’t pressed to his chest anymore and he worked his hand in between us so he could get to my pussy. Well, to my clit. He started rubbing my clit and my eyes rolled back into my head.

“Ahhh!” I cried out. David started to slowly pull out at the same time and I had so many sensations going through me that I couldn’t help but cry out. I dug my fingers into Nathan’s shoulders and felt my pussy spasm around him and my ass around David.

“Oh Samantha,” David moaned. “I’m gonna cum, soon.”

“Me too,” Nathan sighed. He started rubbing my clit harder and I just grunted, trying to rock my hips as fast as I could. I was lost in all the feelings I was having and felt like I turned into an animal. “Shit she’s going off on us!” David started pushing in me again and Nathan squeezed my clit and that was it, I came.

“Oh my fuck yes!” I screamed. All my muscles grabbed both cocks as I came, and I felt David cum in me and Nathan cried out and he came in his condom. David cumming in my ass was awesome. It was hot and wet and felt like it coated me. I loved it. I kept on grunting, working my hips trying to cum more.

“Samantha, you’re going to squeeze my cock off!” David yelped. I felt him slowly withdraw, then he was out of me. Then Nathan grabbed my waist and lifted me off him. I got on my knees beside him, I wasn’t finished cumming and I wanted more so I got on my back and started rubbing myself.

“Damn!” Nathan laughed. “Look at that!” I had my eyes closed tight, legs spread wide (one hanging over Nathan’s legs) and just rubbing my clit like there was no tomorrow. After a few moments I came again, crying out then collapsing on the bed. “She’s leaking your cum on my bed,” he laughed. “I never thought I’d see that.” I sighed deeply, feeling sleepy. I was worn out.

“Let’s get cleaned up Nathan,” David said. “Then we’ll get her cleaned up.” They both got off the bed and then I fell asleep.

I don’t know how much longer but I woke up in David’s arms. I didn’t let him know I was awake though, because he and Nathan were talking and I didn’t want to disturb them. I could feel Nathan on the other side of me and I listened.

“She loves you a lot to let you do this,” Nathan said softly. “Who else would let their man fuck another guy? Or let one fuck him?”

“I know,” David whispered. “I love her too. I can’t believe that she was begging me to fuck her in the ass. She got off on seeing us do it, you know.”

“I know. I hope next time you last longer in her ass though, she didn’t get to really feel what it’s like!”

“I hope she let’s me do it again, I wanted our first time to be just us so we could go slow.”

“Sorry,” Nathan whispered. “She asked for it.”

“No, I know and it’s ok,” David laughed softly. “But next time I’m going to fuck her little ass the right way… with her on her back. I want to see her face. I want her to see mine when I’m in her.”

“Is that why you like it on your back?” Nathan asked. “So you can see my face? So I can see yours?”

“Yea,” he whispered softly.

“Not to change the subject, but who did that to her breast?” I stiffened in David’s arms and he looked at me. I gave him what I hoped was a pleading look that said ‘Don’t tell.’ He looked back at Nathan.

“I didn’t, that’s for damn sure. Don’t worry about it.” He pulled me closer to him and I wrapped my arms around him.

“She up?” Nathan asked. David nodded. “Good morning, Sammi.”

“Morning Nathan,” I said softly. I didn’t feel embarrassed about lying there naked with him, I felt free actually. I had been with both of them, I loved it, and I didn’t feel ashamed.

“How you feeling?” He asked.

“Like I got fucked three ways from Sunday,” I laughed. “I don’t think I can move, my legs feel all tingly.” Both David and Nathan laughed and David hugged me closer to him.

“Next time, it’ll last longer,” he whispered. “And you’ll really know what it’s like.” I felt Nathan press his chest against my back.

“Do I get to be there next time?” He asked softly, his breath tingling my ear.

“I really liked it, the both of you inside me at the same time,” I smiled at David. “So yea, next time I want it I’ll call you up and we can do it again. That ok David?”

“That’s just fine with me. Now let’s get some more sleep,” he grinned. I nodded, and kissed him, then turned in his arms and faced Nathan. I kissed him too, then we smiled at each other.

“See,” he whispered, “we can share him. No more jealousy.”

“I wasn’t jealous of you,” I whispered back.

“No but I was of you.” I smiled at him and kissed him again.

“You two, I’m going to get jealous if you don’t stop!” David teased. “There’s no need to be jealous, I love you both. In different ways, but I love you both.”

“I love you too, David,” I whispered, turning in his arms again to face him.

“Me too, man,” Nathan whispered. He wrapped his arms around me and I drifted off to sleep between them.

I woke up before David and Nathan did, and I crawled out from their arms and made me way to Nathan’s dresser. After searching I finally found a pair of his boxers and then I went to his closet and got one of his shirts. I looked at them lying on the bed and smiled. They were lying side by side, looking satisfied and worn out. I left the room going to the bathroom. I took off my thigh highs that were now torn, then put the boxers and shirt on. I put my hair up then turned to the door. David was standing there.

“You weren’t in my arms anymore,” he said softly. “I woke up and you weren’t there.”

“I wanted to get some clothes on and get something to eat,” I told him.

“I thought you left,” he said softly.

“Why would you think that?”

“I don’t know,” he smiled. “Maybe because I’d never done what we did last night, and you’ve never done it either. I got a little scared and thought you did too.”

“I told you, I wanted last night. I’m not embarrassed, or ashamed, or scared. I know that you love me, and I love you.”

“Wow, ok,” he grinned. “So we can do this again?”

“I hope so! I liked it a lot.” I walked over to him. “I really liked you in my ass,” I whispered.

“Really??” He asked in surprise. I nodded. “So we can do that again?”

“Yes, I hope so,” I whispered. “Next time I’ll be on my back so you can watch my face,” I smiled.

“Deal,” he smiled back. I kissed him softly, and he moaned. “I can’t believe you love me this much.”

“Better believe it,” I smiled. After that, we went into the kitchen and he fixed breakfast. Nathan came in shortly and we all ate together, and there weren’t any weird feelings at all. I guess sharing each other made us a little stronger. I had lied to Nathan when I told him that I wasn’t jealous of him because I was in a way; but now I wasn’t.

On the way home David told me he loved me for being so open with him and his sexuality.

“Well,” I said, “what choice do I have?”

“I would never do anything without your permission, Sammi. If it made you feel bad then I would not do it at all.” I looked over at him.

“It doesn’t make me feel bad,” I said. “It turns me on that you feel what you feel, and I want you to be totally happy. If that means we have someone else in our bed to satisfy feelings in you that I can’t, then that’s what we do.”

“You satisfy me in everyway, Samantha.”

“David, I love you but bullshit. I can’t make love to you the way Nathan does, and that’s fine. As long as you don’t ever do it without me, I don’t care. I liked watching you two.” I watched his face, he looked surprised and happy at the same time.

“Ok. Only with your permission,” he said softly. I grinned at him. We pulled into our building’s parking lot and he found us a space. We both got out of the car and we looked at each other over the car roof. “So this is a new chapter for both of us.”

“Yep, and I think it’s going to be fun!”

After our threesome, David and I got closer emotionally and sexually. We shared our feelings more, didn’t leave anything unsaid and we fought a little less. Not like we fought all the time we didn’t, but before we were afraid to really talk to each other about what we were feeling and we would end up arguing. Sexually, we made love more passionately, and we couldn’t get enough of each other. Maybe we were trying to prove that we didn’t need someone else in our bed, I don’t know; but things got more intense. Sometimes we would make love for hours at a time, and that’s not including foreplay time. By the time we would both cum, we were both too tired to even do anything but cuddle and fall asleep in each other’s arms.

Index

Back

Next