The party soon resumed its course, with small groups forming again.  There was a lot of talk about the sex show that had just occurred, especially in the small group that I was in, which included Emily, Beth, Gary, and I.

The conversation was a bit awkward at first, but then got easy.  Emily confirmed that she had been a virgin, and Gary offered that I had been as well, which I wasn’t sure I wanted to share, but felt good about later, especially considering what Emily had done.

Although Emily hadn’t been the one to take my virginity, as that was done by Laney, she was the first girl to make me cum.  That made her smile.  Emily said that breaking her hymen hurt a little at first, but then it felt okay later just before I came.  Beth confirmed that it hurt when she had lost her virginity a couple years earlier, but that at least Emily was able to have an orgasm first.

As the party continued, I began to drink some beer from the keg, and snack a little.  Some weed was brought out, and about half of the partygoers partook.  But I didn’t feel like getting stoned that evening.  I wound up chatting with most of the party guests throughout the evening, but usually would return to my friends after a while.

At one point, Laney let me know that many of the party guests were going to crash at the house that night, and that I was more than welcome to stay in her bed.  She had already invited Emily to do the same, and Emily had accepted.  I quickly agreed.

I found out a little later that Beth and Gary had put dibs on the couches in the living room, and that Tony would be sleeping with Lisa, who, as part of sorority leadership, had a bedroom in the house.  I also found out later that, although Zach and Susie were a couple, they had never had intercourse.  Susie was a virgin, although that wasn’t the first time she’d given Zach a blowjob.

Emily didn’t have much beer, but she did take a few hits of weed.  She was the first to go upstairs, take a shower, and go to bed.  As president of the sorority, Laney got the master bedroom with its own bathroom.  Laney told Emily she could shower there.

A little later, Laney got everyone’s attention and explained that, although the house had a very large water heater, they should stagger their showers, use the shower in the main bathroom upstairs, since Emily was already sleeping in her bedroom, preferably go two at a time to help scrub each other, and keep the shower time as short as possible.

Over the next hour or two, the crowd started to thin out as showers were taken and people went to bed.  After showering, some of the girls went into the kitchen, or into the first floor bedroom, got dressed, and went home.  But most partiers were going to stay the night, including all four guys.

Toward the end of the evening, there was only a couple groups chatting, as well as Laney and Maggie checking everything and tidying up.

I wound up talking with Gary, Beth, and Maria, us being a group of four freshmen.  Maria is super shy, even more than Emily or I.  When the question of the butt plugs came up in conversation, she got embarrassed.  But Beth took the lead.  Beth explained that Maggie was Lisa’s assistant during the body painting, which occurred in Maggie’s room, rather than the kitchen, where Lisa did her painting.  Beth said she was the last girl to be painted by Lisa, and that when she went into Maggie’s room, Maria was bent over and Maggie was lubing up a glass butt plug to insert into Maria.

Maria looked a little embarrassed, but took over the story, which kind of got long.  Maria explained that she had become really good friends with Maggie at the beginning of the semester when Maggie became her sorority sister mentor.  Lisa had painted Maria right before painting Maggie, and Maggie had asked Maria to stay and assist Lisa with painting Maggie.  Maria diverted, for a moment, to say quietly that Maggie was known in the sorority as the “Anal Queen,” because she liked anal sex.  Maria made us promise not to say anything to anyone else, although I later found out it was pretty common knowledge, and Maggie didn’t really care if anyone else knew.

After painting Maggie as the White Queen, Maggie announced that she needed one more thing to complete the job.  The White Queen needed to meet the Anal Queen, so Maggie retrieved her favorite butt plug from the drawer of her nightstand, along with a tube of anal lube.  With Lisa rolling her eyes, and Maria a bit embarrassed, Maggie proceeded to lube up the butt plug, bend over and insert it into her ass.  Then a discussion about butt plugs occurred.  Maria confessed that she was a true virgin, never having even touched a cock, she was intrigued, and that Maggie convinced her to put one in too.  That’s when Beth came in.

Beth then took over the story.  After some laughter and explanation, Maggie lubed and inserted a clear butt plug into Maria.  Maria said it hurt at first, especially at the wide part of the plug.  But it kind of felt good, in a strange way.  Beth apparently found it all kind of funny, but Maggie said she should try it too.  Maggie said she even had a third butt plug in her nightstand that she would let Beth use.  At first, Beth was not into it.  But, after Lisa was done painting Beth, and before Beth moved on to paint Lisa, Maggie asked one final time.  Beth agreed.  So Maggie lubed and inserted the third glass butt plug into Beth.  Beth agreed that it hurt a little, but she also kind of liked it once it was in.

“But what if you have to, you know,” Gary asked.

“Oh, you just take it out, and then put it back in,” Beth said.

“Have you had to do that?” Gary asked.

Beth nodded, and then Maria also nodded, looking a little sheepish.

“So how are you guys?” Maggie asked, joining our little group.

We said we were doing good.  Maggie said that Laney was clearing a couple more partygoers from the other group to hit the shower, so we needed to wait a bit more.  Beth said that she and Gary could go last, since they were taking the living room couches.  Maggie agreed that made sense.

But then there was a brief moment of awkward silence, as if it was clear that we had been talking quietly and then interrupted.

“So what are you guys talking about,” Maggie asked with a smile.

Maria looked down and embarrassed.  But Beth just blurted it out.

“Oh, we were just talking about the butt plugs,” Beth said.  “How that came about.”

“Oh, yeah,” Maggie replied.  “Do you still like them?”

“Mmm hmm,” Beth acknowledged.  “But I wouldn’t want to make it a habit.  It’s a bit uncomfortable, especially when you sit down.”

Maria nodded, followed by some laughter.

“Yeah, I just love them,” Maggie declared.  “And I love anal.  But only if I’ve got a vibe.”

“A vibe?” Gary asked.

“Yeah, a vibrator,” Maggie said.  “A dick in my ass and a vibe on my clit and I cum hard.”

There was another round of laughter.

“Seriously,” Maggie added.  “You should try it.”

“Yeah, I don’t think so,” Beth responded.

“Well, if you ever wanna try, come talk to me and I’ll give you a few tips,” Maggie said.

Beth smiled.

“Looks like someone is excited about that,” Maggie noted, looking over at Gary, and then down to his crotch.

Gary had a partial erection that was visibly growing by the moment.

“Oh geeze,” Beth declared, rolling her eyes.  “Does that excite you?”

Gary shrugged his shoulders cocked his head, and smiled.

Beth shook her head.

“You should try it,” Maggie said.  “At least once to see if you like it.”

Beth pondered.

“I bet you would,” Maggie said.

By that time Gary had a nearly full erection.

“In fact, now that you’ve had the plug in you for a while, it’d be easy,” Maggie added.

Beth pondered some more.

“Why don’t we just go have you try it in my room,” Maggie offered.  “I’ll help.”

Gary looked delighted at the suggestion.  Beth still seemed reluctant, but smiled at him.

“You want to?” Beth asked Gary.

Gary nodded.

“Alright, we can try it,” Beth said.  “But you need to go slow.”

Gary nodded again.

“So let’s go to my room,” Maggie said with a smile.

The three of them started off toward the hallway.

“Come on you two,” Maggie said to Maria and I, looking back.

“Us?” I asked, pointing to my chest.

“Mmm hmm,” Maggie said.  “I want Maria to see, and I think you might be getting some ass too.”

Maggie slapped her own ass and smiled.

Gary and Beth laughed.

I felt a huge surge of blood immediately fluff my penis.

We all went into Maggie’s bedroom.  Maggie closed the door.

“Hop on the bed,” Maggie said to Beth, as she pulled the covers completely back.  “Don’t worry about getting paint on the sheets.  I’m gonna wash ‘em tomorrow anyway.”

Beth looked a bit nervous again, but climbed up onto the bed.

“Doggie style,” Beth instructed, as she opened her nightstand drawer and pulled out a black tube of lube, as well as two chrome colored objects that I immediately recognized as vibrators.

Maria and I stayed at the base of the bed to observe.  Beth got into position as Maggie and Gary both got onto the bed, Gary from behind and Maggie to the side.

Maria looked over at me, down at my crotch, then smiled.

I looked down.  I had a full hard-on.

“So first we need to take this out,” Maggie announced.

Maggie grabbed the sides of the base of the glass butt plug that was in Beth’s ass.

“As I pull, you push a little, like we talked about,” Maggie instructed.

Beth had put her hand on her butt like earlier that evening, and turned her head in an effort to watch what was happening.

Pulling the plug out of Beth’s ass opened her anus really wide, causing Beth to groan before the widest part was reached and the conical shape forced the plug out.  Beth’s puckered ass immediately closed.

Maggie set the clear glass butt plug with blue accents down on the bed next to Beth.

“Okay, so we’re going to do just like the plug, okay?” Maggie said.

Beth nodded.

Maggie grabbed the lube, flipped open the top, and poured out a generous helping on her left hand as Gary got into position on his knees behind Beth.

Maggie thoroughly lubed Gary’s cock, which only had traces of green paint on the head, so there was no color smears.  It was just a gleaming freshly lubed hard cock.

“So I need you to just stay still, okay?” Maggie said to Gary, while holding the base of his cock with her left hand.

Gary nodded.

“So push back and push out as you do,” Maggie said to Beth.  “You can go slow.”

Beth maneuvered her body to line up her asshole with the head of Gary’s cock.  Maggie helped by pointing it at her anus.

Beth took a deep breath, looked forward and gave a slight groan and pushed back against the hard cock as we all watched.

It didn’t take long.  The head of Gary’s penis popped into Beth, who gave another groan and looked down.

“Just push out if you want to relieve the pressure,” Maggie said, letting go of Gary’s cock.

“Okay,” Beth muttered, still looking down.

Beth slowly moved her but back, impaling herself on more of Gary’s cock.

“How’s that feel?” Maggie asked.

“Different,” Beth said quietly.

“Mmm hmm,” Maggie replied.

As Beth slowly worked her body back and forth, Maggie handed one of the chrome vibrators to Beth, who paused her movement and turned the device on.  I heard it buzz.

Beth moved the tip of the vibrator down to her pussy and moaned audibly when it rested against her clit.

“Does that feel good?” Maggie asked.

“Mmm hmm,” Beth confirmed.

Maggie looked over to Gary, who smiled.

“So fuck her ass really slow,” Maggie instructed.

Gary, holding onto the sides of Beth’s hips with his hands, followed Maggie’s direction and slowly fucked Beth’s ass.  Blue paint from Beth’s body started to blend with the anal lube on Gary’s cock.  Beth moaned some more.

“Speed up a little,” Maggie said to Gary, who immediately did as he was told.

Beth’s moaning got louder.

“Good,” Maggie reassured.

The anal sex went on for a little while, with both Beth and Gary moaning.

“Now pause for a bit,” Maggie said to Gary.

Gary slowed down and then froze in place, his cock half way buried in Beth.

Beth had what appeared to be a huge orgasm.  Her body shook and pulsed as she said ‘fuck’ repeatedly, then she lunged forward, her ass still twitching, buy causing Gary’s cock to pop out of her.

Beth went flat onto the bed and set the vibrator next to her.

“Well, I think that worked for Beth,” Maggie laughed, as she picked up the vibrator and turned it off.

Beth, still breathing heavy and laying facedown on Maggie’s bed, used her hands to spread her ass open, exposing glistening blue stained anal lube all around her puckered hole.

“Fuck my ass,” Beth said strongly.

Maggie looked over at Gary with a smile.  Gary seemed quite surprised.

“Fuck my ass,” Beth said again.

“Well,” Maggie urged.

Gary leaned over Beth and, with some assistance from Maggie, put the head of his cock against Beth’s  to each side of asshole and pushed inside her once again.  Beth gave a quiet groan.

“Yeah,” Beth muttered.  “Fuck my ass.”

That’s just what Gary did.  He went slowly at first, moving his knees up next to Beth’s sides to support his lower weight, and used his arms to keep his upper body off Beth.

As Gary continued to fuck Beth up the ass, Maggie turned to Maria and I.

“You wanna have a try?” she asked Maria.

“I don’t know,” Maria replied meekly.

“Up to you,” Maggie said.

“I think it’ll hurt,” Maria said, glancing down at my rock-hard cock.

“It does a little at first,” Maggie agreed.  “But then it’s pretty good, as you can see,” Maggie continued, glancing back over at Beth and Gary.

Maria nodded.

“I’ll try it,” Maria said.  “But if I don’t like it, I wanna stop.”

“Of course,” Maggie reassured.

Maria climbed onto Maggie’s bed and got into position on all fours on the other side of Maggie, leaving Maggie in between Beth and Maria.  Maggie waved me to come onto the bed behind Maria.  I could see pinkness from the inside of Maria’s anus through the center of the clear glass butt plug.  Maria looked back at me over her shoulder.  She was smiling, but also looked a little nervous.

Beth and Gary were still moaning as Gary continued to fuck Beth up the ass.  I was surprised Gary lasted that long.  But, then again, he had already cum once that evening.  I was hoping that, having cum myself earlier, I could last more than a few seconds in Maria’s ass.

Maggie gently pulled the butt plug out of Maria’s ass.  Maria gave a very quiet moan as the widest part of the plug opened her sphincter wide.  Unlike Beth, Maria’s asshole gaped open for a second before closing up.

I got into position behind Maria.  Maggie lubed my cock, just like she had done with Gary.

“Now don’t move,” Maggie said to me.  “Just let her back up.”

I nodded, as Maggie held the base of the shaft of my cock in a way that lined the head up against Maria’s dark blue painted hole, just above her unpainted and virgin inner pussy lips.

“Okay,” Maggie said to Maria.

I felt Maria push her body back against my cock.  The head smashed up against her asshole, but didn’t penetrate.

“Push out,” Maggie encouraged.

Maria pushed back harder and the head of my cock popped into her body.  The feeling was immediately intense.  Maria’s anus squeezed my cock hard.  It was super tight.

Maria was gasping a bit, but Maggie was reassuring her.

“Just take it slow,” Maggie said.

“Mmm hmm,” Maria moaned.

“Uhh,” I heard Gary moan loudly.

“Oh yeah,” Beth replied.

Gary moaned some more.

The scene drew all of our attention as Gary pumped a load of semen deep into Beth’s ass.

I remained frozen, with my hands on Maria’s hips and just the head and an inch or two of the shaft of my cock in Maria’s tight ass.

Maggie turned her attention back to Maria and I, handing Maria a chrome vibrator that Maggie had turned on.

Maria did just what Beth had done, and used the vibrator on her pussy and clit.  I could even slightly feel the vibrations on the shaft of my cock.

“Just hold still,” Maggie said to me in a whisper.

I nodded, and noticed that Gary had lifted himself off Beth, his cock deflated and streaked with blue body paint.

“You can use one of the towels over there,” Maggie said to Gary and Beth, nodding her head over to the sheets on the floor with towels and other items stained with various colors of body paints.

Gary and Beth both smiled at me as they crawled off the bed and saw my cock buried in Maria’s ass.

“Was that good?” Maggie asked.

“Oh yeah,” Beth confirmed.  “Much better than I thought.”

Maggie and Gary laughed.

Maria continued to work on her clit with the vibrator as Gary and Beth cleaned the excess lube off their bodies with some of the towels.

“You guys have fun,” Beth said, as she and Gary left the room to rejoin the party.

“How are you doing?” Maggie asked Maria as soon as the door was closed again.

“Mmm, okay,” Maria muttered.  “But I think it’s just too big for me to be able to cum.”

“Hmm,” Maggie replied.  “Before we have him take it out, let’s try one more thing.”

“Okay,” Maria hissed.

“Back up on it a little more,” Maggie said, somewhat to my surprise.

Maria moan as a couple more inches of my lubricated cock shaft went into her body.  It was a new sensation, as the head and sensitive area on my cock were beyond the pressure of her sphincter and into the warm inner depths of her rectum.

I moaned.  So did Maria.

“Push it in a little more,” Maggie told me.

I did, with the same result.  More moaning from both of us.

“A little more,” Maggie said twice more, until my entire cock was buried inside of Maria’s ass.

Maria moaned loudly.  I wasn’t sure if it was pleasure, pain, or some combination of the two.

“Stay still,” Maggie directed.  “Don’t fuck her.  Just be still.”

I nodded.  I could feel the tip of vibrator directly against my scrotum.  It felt amazing.  But the head and shaft of my cock were not getting a lot of stimulation, so I didn’t feel like an orgasm was approaching.

But Maria had one right then.  She moaned repeatedly and her body trembled.  But more noticeable was the repeated strong clenching of her sphincter on the base of my cock.  It was intense.  Unlike Beth, Maria’s body didn’t jerk around, and she managed to keep fully impaled on my cock through her entire orgasm, which meant I could feel every pulse.

“Good girl,” Maggie reassured.

A few moments later, Maria pulled the vibrator away from her pussy, then turned it off.  She laid her head down on a pillow she pulled toward her, then took a deep breath.

“Well, I think that worked for you,” Maggie said.

“Mmm hmm,” Maria agreed.  “But it’s really big and starting to hurt again.”

“Okay, well he’ll take it out now,” Maggie replied.  “I have more plans for him anyway.”

I slowly pulled my cock out of Maria’s ass.  Like Gary, my cock had streaks of dark blue body paint that had transferred from Maria’s ass.

Like before, Maria’s ass gaped open for a moment before closing up, then she fell forward.

I was pretty sure I knew what would be happening next, and I wasn’t mistaken.

Maggie replaced Maria in front of me, getting on all fours.  She convinced Maria to stay and help, so Maria took Maggie’s spot.  Maria smiled at me.  I smiled back.

Maria removed the butt plug from Maggie’s ass and added more lube to my cock and Maggie’s butthole.

“Just put it in,” Maggie directed.

A combination of me pushing forward and Maggie pushing back caused about half my cock to glide into Maggie.  She wasn’t nearly as tight as Maria, but still much tighter than any of the vaginas that my cock had been inside earlier in the evening.

Maggie did most of the work.  She fucked my cock, which transferred some of Maria’s dark blue body paint onto Maggie’s white painted asshole.

Maggie picked up the same vibrator that Maria had used, and put it directly on her clit as we continued to have anal intercourse.

Maggie’s moaning was loud, and Maria kept glancing back and forth between Maggie’s head, the penetration, and my face, causing us both to smile each time.  It was an incredible sight.  I could feel an orgasm start to build.

“It’s so fuckin’ big,” Maggie hissed.

“I know,” Maria chuckled.

Maggie pushed herself hard against my body, taking in the entire length of my cock, then froze in place.

Maggie came hard.  It was more like the way Maria had cum than Beth, but with a bit more jerking around.  I wasn’t able to feel the pulsing of her sphincter as much, but Maggie was much louder in her moaning than Maria had been.  I hardly had any time to enjoy the sensation of the vibrator against my scrotum when Maggie was done.  But she kept my cock in her ass and rocked back and forth as she turned off the vibrator.

“Fuck me,” Maggie directed.  “Fuck me Alex.”

I looked over at Maria, whose eyes were wide, then turned my attention back to Maggie.  I fucked Maggie’s ass for the next couple minutes as she moaned and my orgasm built.  I decided to push all the way back inside Maggie as my penis pulsed out my second load of semen for the night, deep within Maggie’s rectum.  It felt amazing.

“Yeah, Alex,” Maggie hissed.  “Cum in me.”

After I was spent, Maggie lurched forward, my cock puling out of her and already starting to shrink.

We used the towels to clean up excess lube, and rejoined the party.

However, there was hardly anyone left in the main room.  Laney approached us.

“I hear you’ve ha a little fun in there,” Laney said with a smile.

I looked over to see Gary and Beth talking with each other, and assumed that they had spilled the beans to Laney.

Maggie laughed.

“Corrupting our young sisters,” Laney declared.

“Mmm hmm,” Maggie retorted.  “Proudly.”

“Okay, well are you ready to head upstairs and shower?” Laney asked me.  “It’s my turn now.”

I nodded, said goodnight to Maggie and Maria, waved goodnight to Beth and Gary, and followed Laney up the stairs.

Maggie’s bedroom was mostly dark, with the only light coming from the bathroom.  Maggie had a nice big bedroom with a king size bed.  I could see the back of Emily’s head on a pillow, with her body under the covers on the far side of the bed.  It was clear that Emily was asleep.

Laney took my hand and led me quietly into the bathroom.  She closed the door and smiled at me.

I watched as she turned on the shower and got a couple clean towels from a rack and set them on the counter next to the shower.

“Come on in,” she said.

I followed Laney into the shower, which she had turned on pretty hot.  Red and black body paint immediately started to run off her body and swirl down the drain, then a bunch more colors as I got some water on my body.  It wasn’t the biggest shower, but we managed to make it work, helping to wash each other’s bodies with the help of a wash towel that had obviously been used by others, as there was residue from lots of colors.

I thoroughly enjoyed washing Laney’s boobs and butt, which she smiled at me as I did, knowing full well that I was copping a feel.  It also felt great to have her wash my cock and balls, and even the crack of my ass, which she had me lean over for.  I did the same with her, which was more than a bit exciting.  I couldn’t believe that my cock started to inflate for the third time.  But it didn’t get erect, so I’m not sure if Laney really noticed.

It was truly amazing to see her sexy naked body appear from underneath all of the paint.

We got out of the shower and dried ourselves off, before tossing the towels on a pile of other towels in the corner of the bathroom, turning off the bathroom light, and heading to bed.  I could barely see where I was going, so Laney led me by the hand, us both stark naked and unpainted.

“Do you want the middle?” Laney asked me in a whisper.

“Sure,” I whispered back.

I crawled into the center of the bed as Laney held the covers back.  Then she crawled in too, leaving me between her and Emily.  Laney asked me to cuddle her for a bit.  We both feel asleep.

 

Copyright 2018 by kid charlemagne.