My First Time
"Two on One"
Season Two: Episode Eleven
"Season Finale"
Copyright © 2008
Disclaimer: This story is based on characters created originally by TVM and are copyrighted to him, any reposting or archiving without written permission is an infringement on the copyright of this series. So in other words You damn well better ask before you steal it.
Feedback: Every author in his or her own way makes it a point to ask for feedback when posting a story, well me I don't usually. But there are several reasons as to why a reader should consider taking the time to give it. The simple fact is that giving some form of feedback is truly the most important thing a reader can do after reading and enjoying a story. Hopefully in the process providing that author with at least one viable reason as to what you liked about the story. This small amount of time spent will no doubt inspire the author to write more and possibly at a quicker pace, knowing that they have a fan base who are waiting on their next works. So thanks for the feedback and please keep it comin.
Summary: In the ALL NEW 11th episode of Season Two of 'My First Time', what happens when two members of a group of three truly 'best friends' start dating? Could it be awkward? Could it be that nothing really changes? Could it mean the end of the 'Mustang Gang'? Could it be a new beginning for the threesome, literally? Or could it be that one of the threesome has some plans of her own. That's the dilemma facing, Sarah, Cara and Piper, better known to their many friends and few enemies at Black Rock High as the uber popular, 'Mustang Gang'. It seems that Sarah and Piper, have become, well, more than just friends. Fortunately, for the twosome, their mutual best friend, Cara, approves completely and even encourages the romance along. Leaving them alone for the summer when she takes a cultural tour of the far east. Only to return with a shocking secret of her own and an even more shocking invitation for her two 'best friends'.
Original Airdate: Wednesday, August 27, 2008 @ 8:00 p.m.
(followed by an ALL NEW 'Megan in Charge!')
Story Codes: fff, ff, oral
"Piper, Sarah and Cara" That was the way everyone at Black Rock High referred to us, mostly. While everyone else referred to as the Mustang Gang. Simply for the fact that, Sarah had a smokin classic mustang and just loved showing it off downtown. We were such good friends because we had so many things in common. Such as all three of us being cheerleaders, straight A students, local models, and popular beyond our own knowledge. We all loved the same kind of food (Mexican), music (Blues, Rock ,Pop and R&B), and movies (mindless action films and cartoons). So everyone was quiet surprised when the news broke that there was in fact a major difference between the three. That was the news that myself (Piper Kennedy) and Sarah (Lane) had started dating. The news was the hot topic around school for more than a week. Everyone wondering what would become of the "Mustang Gang" now that two of us had pretty much told the world we were gay.
Wait. I'm getting ahead myself, maybe I should give you some details that might give you a better perspective on our relationship with a little "pre-story" history lesson. Sarah and I have been friends since first grade, "instant best friends" is the way my mom puts it. We were as close as any two girls could be without being in a relationship. Lots of late nights in the other's room giggling and laughing till our sides hurt about every concievable topic. Boys being the primary one on most occasions. Several times growing up though we began acting like children and got mad at each other and it'd be a few weeks or in our last and most nasty fight of all, it was nearly 8 months before we spoke again. I think it was then that we realized we needed each other more than we needed to be right. That's when I realized that Sarah meant the world to me, although I kept denying the fact that I was falling in love with her. That is until my 14th birthday came and Sarah's mom threw me this incredible party. That night me, Sarah and some of our mutual friends had a very memorable slumber party. Which featured two notable events. Us (meaning me and Sarah) meeting Cara (who was there as a cousin of one Sarah's friends) for the first first time and our first kiss (Sarah and mine's I mean), in a game of spin the bottle. I knew instantly that no matter how hard I fought it, I was in love with Sarah Lane.
Well anyway, fearing she'd hate if she ever knew, I hid it the best I could for the next year, while Cara became an integral member of our group. Helping both of us through some tough times. One of those was my tear filled confession that I was in love with Sarah, which came while crying on Cara's shoulder. In reality, that was probably the only reason that Sarah ever found out, cause Cara locked me in a room with Sarah at the New Year's end dance and forced me to tell her. You can just imagine what I was planning to do to her when Sarah, in my mind, would turn me down and tell me to get lost. Little did I know, but Cara already know the outcome. Sarah started crying and admitted she loved me.
"Why didn't you tell me this months ago?" She asked as tears came to her eyes. "I feel the same way."
My only reply was a soft kiss on the lips and this time I wasn't pretending not to like it. So in essence Cara was the reason we got together at all. I sometimes think she wanted us together as much as we wanted to be together. Which as you'll see as the story unfolds is not such a far fetched conclusion considering what she ended up talking us into.
So, the school year came to an end and Cara's family (bunch of rich fucks, I love them though), sent her on a cultural tour of the far east. She was gone for like two months. Although she stayed in touch daily with email and phone calls it was still nice to have Sarah ALL to myself for an entire two months. We started getting heavier and heavier in our make out sessions until making out just wasn't enough for either of us and we had to make the all important decision, that is if we wanted to take that next step.
Just so you know, this story ain't about my REAL first time, so with this next part I'll give a few details and move on. My sweet 16 was on a saturday night and Sarah showed up, after disappearing during the party, with her Mustang and we went up on Town Mountain and after some initial nervousness, we made love. It was magical and altogether mind numbing, the things that girl did to me still makes my nipples hard. I also like to think I made her night worth while too. Which she later assured me that I did. So there went my virginity and I have to say, to this day I still don't regret it. After that we started doing it like rabbit's, neither able to get enough of the other, until we laid there panting for breath, exhausted. Trust me this happened more than once. And on an important side note, mine and Sarah's parents knew about the relationship and still let us spend the night together often.
"Well, she can't knock you up" Mom said in a particularly memorable quote.
So when Cara returned (we met her at the airport), both figured our nightly love making sessions would soon come to an end. Little did we know at that time, that we would be presented an oppurtunity that would potentially add some REAL spice to our love making.
You could sense the change in Cara, she was glowing from head to toe, and it wasn't the fabulous tan she'd gotten. Which was pretty sexy looking I might add, but there was something else. I couldn't quite explain it at the time, it was just there. She hugged me first and nearly took my breath with her perfume, it was so sexy. Our reunion was tearful and hug filled and I didn't really realize how much I'd missed her since she'd been gone. Sarah was obviously feeling the same thing as she never left her side for a minute. It was a lot of fun hanging out again, just the three of us, we went shopping, ate till we were stuffed and watched movies till they threw us out of the theater. Cara was exhausted and being that her house was on the far side of town, she begged Sarah to let her crash in her room. Which Sarah of course agreed to. That was the decision that I think changed our lives forever. Due to the fact that if she had went home, we may never have found out Cara's 'big summer secret'.
"I FELL IN LOVE" She squealed as we finally dragged it out of her. "Oh my god, I still miss her."
"Her?" I asked jumping from Sarah's bean bag to the bed and crashing down aside Cara. "You fell in love with a..."
"A FUCKIN GIRL?" Sarah asked as she pushed Cara into me playfully.
"Yeh, I've been converted" She giggled. "Her names Julie and she is soooooo hottttttt."
"No shit?" I asked as Cara laid down, her head now on my thigh.
"No shit, I fell in love" She said and smiled with a glow of only someone in love could have.
"Liar" Sarah said as I looked at her and she grinned down at Cara with a challenging expression on her face. "If you were so in love with this girl, did you do it with her?"
"No" Cara said, "We planned to but every time we were alone something happened."
"I'll bet you never even kissed her" Sarah said crossing her legs over Cara's thighs and leaning down, laying along her body and meeting her gaze. "I'll bet you're makin it up."
"Bite me, Mustang girl" Cara said as we all laughed and to my absolaute shock, Cara wrapped an arm around Sarah's neck and pulled her down and kissed her. Full on the lips and shoved her tongue into Sarah's mouth and started frenching her. I know I should have been jealous, but for some reason it had the opposite offect on me. It made me hot, really hot and the longer it went on the more I wanted to see it. Both of Cara's hands had now moved to either of Sarah's cheeks as they kissed, which after a few more seconds slowed to a softer gentler kiss, almost like a lovers kiss before Cara pulled away. Sarah had a dazed look on her face as she looked down at her best friend and then up to me.
"I'm convinced" She said almost out of breath.
"I never knew you were such a good kisser" Cara said with a wink as she touched Sarah's face.
"Ditto" Sarah said with a smile.
"So what about you Piper?" Cara asked looking up at me. "Do you believe me?"
"Of course" I said, "I can see you fell for someone."
"Good cause I thought I was gonna have to convince you too" She said with a giggle.
"Well I didn't say I didn't wanna be convinced" I said as Cara smiled, "I mean maybe you are just telling us a pant load for effect."
"So you want me to kiss you?" She asked as she touched my cheek.
"No" I said acting as if it were one of the crazier suggestions ever thought up.
"I didn't make you jealous did I?" She asked with a teasing smile that made me blush.
"No" I said in the same manner as before.
"That made my girl hot" Sarah said as she giggled and kissed my cheek. "You liked watching me kiss Cara huh?"
"Oh my god really?" Cara asked as she sat up and I blushed a few colors never seen before. Pretty much giving away any chance I had to deny anything at this point. "So you wanna kiss me or you wanna see me kiss Sarah again?"
"Both" I said as Sarah and Cara both looked at me with a stunned expression.
"That's cool with me" Cara said looking to Sarah for her approval, "Can I?"
"Fairs fair, I did it so she can to" Sarah said as Cara looked at me with a playful expression and leaned in. I froze for a second and then matched her path, tilting my head and pressing my lips to hers. Our lips started moving softly in time to each other's and I felt her tongue lick my lips, and before long I traded mine for hers and we began frenching. It didn't take long for me to realize this was makin me hotter than texas pavement in summer either. We parted for a second and I saw Cara smile before I tilted my head, then pressing my lips back to hers and turned up the intensity a couple of notches. She responded in kind and kissed me with as much passion as I did her. Finally, even though I didn't wanna stop, I began to worry that Sarah would get upset if I didn't stop. So I pulled away, reluctantly. Cara licked her lips and looked at me with that same look Sarah had when she kissed her. I no doubt had that same look on my face.
"Now that's a welcome home kiss" Cara said with a smile as she blushed again.
"WHOA you guys are so hot together" Sarah said as both of us looked at her, "I mean melting plastic hot."
"I'd say I'll have to agree with that" Cara said smiling at me, "that was hot. Really hot."
"Ummmm....it was ok" I said as both Sarah and Cara laughed.
Then came the suggestion that to this day, I believe Cara had carefully planned. Possibly even setting up this whole kissing scenario so she could bridge the topic.
"Have you guys ever thought about doing a three way?" She asked.
"No" Sarah and I said in unison as Cara's mood seemed to dampen for the moment.
"So you've never thought about it, would you now that I'm asking about it?" She asked as she forged ahead.
"I guess" I said looking to Sarah who looked to be equally as confused as me.
"Come on just tell me, have either of you ever fantasied about it?"
"Well yeah doesn't everyone?" Sarah asked as Cara smiled and replied, "Yeh I think so. Piper?"
"No, but it might be fun" I said honestly as Cara smiled even brighter.
"You wanna do one then?" She asked bluntly.
"With you?" I asked in shock as the whole picture finally came into focus.
"Yes with me" She said poking me in the ribs and making me double over in laughter.
"If it's ok with Piper I will" Sarah said biting her lip as she looked at me nervously.
"You know I won't try and break you guys up right?" Cara asked touching my face gently, "I love both of you."
"Ok, it's cool with me" I said as Cara squealed with excitement and kissed my cheek, and then with a glance toward's my girlfriend she kissed my lips softly. That turned to a more passioniate french a second later as my hands moved to her body and I wondered if she meant now or what. This was making me seriously hot as I felt a hand on my breast as I pulled away from Cara to see Sarah smiling, she then kissed me softly for a second and turned to our mutual friend. They sorta hesistated before kissing themselves, while I watched intently. I noticed then that Cara was only wearing a "wife beater" and a pair of pajama shorts. I stroked the small of her back and felt the shirt rise up under my hand, the touch of her skin under my fingers made me so hot.
"Hey don't leave me out" I said stroking Cara's red hair and watching her grin playfully as she pulled away from Sarah and kissed me again, guiding me back down onto the bed and crawling over me. Kissing my lips like she'd waited a life time to and wrapping her arms under my head, so it laid on her forearms as we trading tongues now passionaitely. She rose a second later and smiled down at me as Sarah joined us at the top of the bed, her hand sliding up Cara's back and lifting her "wife beater" slowly higher and higher. Cara sat up and let Sarah slip it over her head and proudly displayed her incredible body for both of us. Lifting her arms over her head and showcasing it almost. My hands shot instantly to her flat oh so perfectly tanned stomach and stroked up it till they reached her breasts and I cupped them and squeezed. Sarah leaned down and kissed me softly, trading tongues in a moment that felt so right, I'll never forget it. We got lost in the moment and each other, as we always do. Forcing Cara to have to break us up with her giggling.
"I ain't never seen bigger kissing sluts than you two" She said her hand covering her mouth as she laughed out loud.
"Oh you think it's funny huh?" Sarah asked as she kissed Cara softly on the lips and held it. Cara's smiled disappearing as Sarah pulled away and started kissing her neck, she began moaning almost instantly. I rose, as she dropped her arms to her sides, and began kissing her tanned stomach and up her stomach till I reached her breasts and started sucking her nipples, one at a time and harder with each passing second. Her moaning grew louder as we both worked her over, the desire over taking all three of us now as Cara laid her head back and moaned. Seconds later, Sarah had her lay back. Her hips now in my lap, I grasped her shorts in my hands and pulled them down slowly as they started kissing again. Cara raised her hips and after a few seconds of manuevering the shorts were off her body. I could see her tan was one of the "all over" variety with not a tan line to be found on her gorgeous body. I lowered my head and kissed every inch of her stomach as Sarah made love to our best friend's mouth.
"You are like too gorgeous for words" Sarah said stroking her hands up and down Cara's tanned toned body. Cara smiled and replied, "I knew you thought a tan was sexy, it's my present to you."
"I like, I love, I can't get enough" Sarah said as we all three giggled.
"And for you" Cara said looking up at me, "I shaved it, cause you like that right?"
"You did?" I asked as I looked down for the first and saw the bald patch of untouched skin below me. "Ohmigod."
"Pretty sure what you wanted huh?" Sarah asked as she kissed Cara again and both smiled as Cara replied, "yeh, I wanted my best friends to show me how good it can feel."
"You heard the girl" Sarah said as she cirled an arm under Cara's head and kissing her shoulder and up her chest to one of her nipples. "Show the girl how good it feels."
"MMMMMMMM yes ma'am" I said as I scooted back, bringing my head into perfect alignment with Cara's sex and watched them begin to kiss again. I lowered my head and tasted my best friend for the first time. It was so sweet and fresh, like she'd never been touched at all. I stroked my tongue up her slit, appling just the right amount of pressure to the center to make it feel good and then did it again and again until my head was bobbing slowly and I lost count of everything. Cara's moaning brought me back to reality as she broke away from Sarah and moaned loudly arching her back as Sarah held her and begging for more.
"Not so funny anymore huh?" Sarah asked as Cara neared her orgasm with my constant tongue work. I knew also that this being her first time it wouldn't take much at all to bring her off.
"OHMIGOD IT'S SO GOOD" She moaned as Sarah smiled at me and Cara reached for my hand and laced our fingers together, squeezing my hand as she whimpered and I moved my other hand to her heavy stomach and held her as she came for the first time. Jerking and squirming hard as her body exploded in rapture. A few seconds later she gave me my reward as an oozing and bubbling squirt of her honey sweet girl cum found my tongue. I licked every bit of it up and shoved my tongue inside for more as I drained her. She went limp, spent from her first orgasm. Sarah smiled at me as she moved down and kissed me softly, tasting our friends cum for the first time. Then returning to Sarah and kissing her again. "Wow."
"Wow is all you gotta say?" I asked playfully as I moved my hand to below Cara's breasts and felt her heart still racing.
"The only word that describes it" She said with a huge dreamy smile as I crawled over her and we kissed for the longest time. A few minutes later, she watched as Sarah and I went at it in a 69. I never thought being watched could make me so incredibly hot, but it did. I cum harder on Sarah's tongue than I ever had before. It was mind numbing really. With all three of us near exhaustion we headed into the shower and washed each other off. It was weird cause now nothing was out of bounds with us, there was no jealousy or anything when two of us touched each other or kissed for a long moment. It was friends turning into lovers, course all of this might have been because Sarah paid equal attention to both of us the entire time. So a half hour later we all crawled into bed together, Cara in the middle. lol.
"Thank you" Cara said softly to me as Sarah laying sleepin in her arms. "Thank you for letting me share your girl."
"You're our best friend, both of us" I said as she smiled. "We both love you."
"Didn't know you loved me this much though" She said giggling as I blushed. "It was a pretty amazing way to lose my virginity huh?."
"I'd say it was" I said kissing her as she smiled. "Wanna do it again?"
"Maybe" She said looking at Sarah for a moment who stirred and snuggling up closer to Cara before falling back asleep. "I think first I need to find a girl of my own. I wanna fall in love like you guys did."
"Trust me Cara, it's worth the wait" I said gently rubbing Sarah's face and it was no surprise to me, when she woke and smiled up at me. "If you find someone like Sarah you'll be happy for a long time."
That night will always be one of my favorite erotic memories, falling sleep in the arms of the two hottest girls I've ever met and not to mention my two best friends. I slept like a baby and woke to find Cara snuggled up to me and sleeping peacefully with a contented smile on her face. While Sarah was missing. I looked around, letting my eyes adjust to the darkness and spotted her out on the balcony of her room. I kissed Cara's cheek once more as I slipped out of bed and pulled the covers tight to her. Slipping on my robe and joining Sarah, who grinned as she saw me and rose up and kissed me good morning.
"MMMMMM morning my love" She said with a grin.
"Mornin to you too lover" I replied as she pressed her body to mine.
"You still think last night was amazing?" She asked as she wrapped her arms around my waist and my went around her neck as I answered honestly, "Beyond amazing."
"I agree totally, and you're still in love with me?" She asked with a pooched lip look on her face. I smiled and rolled my eyes and replied, but not with words, I kissed her in a way only I could. Feeling her melt into me as we kissed passionately and endlessly for the nexy half hour or longer. Finally being broken up when we heard a light giggly from the door way. We both looked to see Cara smiling at us. I held my arm out and motioned for her to join us as did Sarah. She hesitated for a moment before quickly excepting our invite. Feeling both of our arms wrap around her as she slid in to our hug.
"MMMMMM morning" Cara said giggling as we exchanged soft kisses.
"MMMMMMM and to you" Sarah said as she kissed Cara.
"You guys look so in love" She said with a huge smile. "I would never do anything to break you up, I hope you know that."
"Yeh we do" Both Sarah and I said in unison as we broke out in a fit of giggles. Cara rolling her eyes at our goofiness and asking in a completely straight voice, "So you got any friends you can hook me with?"
"How about we just take turns sharing you?" I asked as Sarah giggled and said, "Now there's an idea I could really get into."
"I don't want you two sluts" Cara said, "I want one of my own."
"I've got a friend who lives like 20 minutes from here" Sarah said, "she might be the slut you're looking for."
"Name?" Cara asked.
"Raegan Lynn Mulkirk" Sarah said, "she's cute and sexy and she's like totally bi-curious."
"Will you gimme her phone number?" Cara asked.
"Even better what ya say we ride over and meet her tonight?"
"Oh ok" Cara said, "but first I gotta get home and say hi to my folks, gimme a ride?"
I guess you could say that was a request that had an easy answer. Cara's parents mobbed her and for some reason never asked why she was a day late, just glad to see her I thought. We waited in the living room while they had a short reunion and then she practically dragged us out the door, very eager to meet this Raegan girl. Raegan's house was only a few miles away from Cara's, didn't take us nearly as long as I thought to reach it. We spotted this hot girl in the front yard, washing a mini van as we pulled in. She was wearing daisy dukes and a bikini top.
"That's her" Sarah said as she turned off the ignition and opened the passengers side door. Raegan washed her hands off and walked towards the car, as Sarah got out.
"She is so fuckin hot" Cara said to me as I opened my door and we got out and circled around the car and met Sarah by the front bumper.
"Where have you been for like the last three months?" Raegan asked pushing Sarah playfully.
"With her" Sarah said smiling as she grabbed my arm and jerked me in front of Cara. "This is my girlfriend, Piper Kennedy. Piper this is Raegan."
"Hey" We both said in unison as everyone laughed. I noticed something right away that Cara couldn't take her eyes off of Raegan, it was like instant attraction.
"This is our friend Cara, Sarah wanted her to meet you" I blurted out as Sarah looked back at me in surprise and Cara nearly fainted. "Sorry I didn't mean to..."
"It's ok, I like people who are upfront" Raegan said looking at Cara and I saw the same thing in her eyes that I had seen in Cara's just moments before. Instant attraction, both smiled nervously and waited for the other to speak.
"Raegan this is Cara" I said trying to break the ice.
"Nice to meet you" Raegan said extending her hand as Cara shook it and Sarah pulled me aside and away from the conversation which slowly started to develope.
"They are so hot together" Sarah said as we stood behind the car and she wrapped her arms around my waist. "Can you imagine watching them go at it?"
"Maybe we won't have to imagine it" I said with a flirting smile as Sarah raised her eyebrows and asked, "You mean a foursome? You kinky thing you."
Written by
Mr. TVM
Wednesday Night on...
(Summer 2008)
* * 8:00 * *
My First Time
* * 8:30 * *
Megan in Charge!
* * 9:00 * *
Poison
* * 9:30 * *
Passing of Seasons